Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

As a film enthusiast with a deep appreciation for the artistry and impact of iconic villains, I can’t help but be captivated by the transformative performances of Heath Ledger as The Joker and Joaquin Phoenix in the more recent portrayal of this enigmatic character.


For several decades, the enigmatic figure of the Joker, DC Comics’ renowned antagonist, has captured our attention through various mediums including films, TV shows, and literature. This notorious character made his first appearance in the debut issue of “Batman” comic book back in 1940. Initially intended to meet his demise during that initial appearance, the Joker was given a reprieve by editorial intervention, ultimately leading him to become Batman’s long-standing adversary.

The Joker, in his comic book versions, is depicted as a brilliant criminal mind. Initially introduced as a psychopath with a twisted sense of amusement, he transformed into a more lighthearted prankster towards the late 1950s. However, he reverted back to his darker self during the early 70s. Throughout his long history, there have been numerous theories about the Joker’s origins. The most well-known explanation is that of him falling into a vat of chemical waste, leading to both his disfigurement and insanity.

In stark contrast to Batman in terms of character and appearance, the Joker is widely regarded by critics as the ideal adversary for the caped crusader. This enduring figure in pop culture continues to captivate audiences and is frequently ranked among the greatest comic book villains and fictional characters. The Joker has made a significant impact across various media, including live-action, animation, and video games. Let’s delve deeper into our selection of top-notch portrayals of Batman’s arch-nemesis.

8 Jared Leto in Suicide Squad (2016) & Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2017)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

Jared Leto’s portrayal of the DC villain, the Joker, in “Suicide Squad” sparked strong reactions from fans, to put it mildly. His depiction of the character was marked by a more contemporary gangster style with tattoos, eye-catching outfits, and even a chrome grill. Although many fans were underwhelmed by how the Joker was portrayed in David Ayer’s film, with the antagonist having limited development in the overly complex adaptation, Leto’s captivating chemistry with his on-screen lover Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie) made his performance more effective than it might have been otherwise.

Leto’s Work Is a Great Effort

In simpler terms, Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of the Joker in “Joker” (2019) was more about his love for violence and psychopathic tendencies as a crime boss, rather than anarchy or chaos. Phoenix found motivation from musicians David Bowie and Alejandro Jodorowsky. A year later, Phoenix’s Joker interacted with Batman in “Zack Snyder’s Justice League” (2021), offering fans a glimpse into what could have been if he had more compelling material and development in “Suicide Squad.” These moments showcase Leto’s potential take on the character.

7 Zach Galifianakis in The Lego Batman Movie (2017)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

In this animated adventure that I absolutely adore, called “The Lego Batman Movie,” released in the US back in 2017, things are heating up in Gotham City. The Joker is planning a hostile takeover, and if Batman truly wants to save his city, he might need to put aside his solitary ways and collaborate with others. It’s an intriguing twist on the classic caper! This film, which boasts impressive animation, superb voice acting, a catchy soundtrack, and side-splitting humor, was widely praised by critics and audiences alike. And financially speaking, it was a massive success, raking in $312 million globally against a production budget of just $80 million.

Galifianakis Is a Hilarious Voice Actor

As a gamer, I’ve always been drawn to the quirky and hilarious performances of Zach Galifianakis. In real life, he’s famous for his memorable roles in movies like “The Hangover” series and the FX show “Baskets.” His distinct voice adds so much charm to projects like “The Lego Batman Movie,” and I was thoroughly entertained by his villainous turn in that animated film. So, it’s no surprise that Zach makes it onto my list of favorite gaming characters – even if he isn’t actually one!

6 Cameron Monaghan in Gotham (2015 – 2019)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

As a dedicated gamer and fan of crime dramas, I can’t help but be blown away by Cameron Monaghan’s exceptional acting in “Gotham.” In this captivating series, I got to witness his mesmerizing performance as both Jerome and Jeremiah Valeska. These identical twin brothers bring the iconic villain, the Joker, to life in their own unique ways.

Monaghan Is Particularly Twisted

Monaghan excelled in portraying two intricately crafted villainous roles on “Gotham,” effortlessly unleashing his mischievousness and inner malevolence in every chilling scene. As both twins evolved into increasingly disturbed versions of the Joker throughout the series, Monaghan’s performance earned him acclaim from fans, critics, and even Mark Hamill for its captivating intensity. The show’s innovative take on the Joker character was brought to life in a remarkable way through Monaghan’s skillful portrayal of the dual roles.

5 Cesar Romero in Batman (1966 – 1968)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

I can’t help but be in awe of Cesar Romero, the man who brought the Joker to life in the iconic 1966 “Batman” series. His over-the-top and campy portrayal of the Clown Prince of Crime left an indelible mark on me as a fan. With his white makeup and smeared red lips, Romero perfectly embodied the villain, making him unforgettable on the small screen.

Romero’s Joker Is Lighter Than Others

Romero’s portrayal of the Joker in the ’60s show was light-hearted and amusing, with him not taking things too seriously. He delighted audiences with his loud, eccentric laugh and vibrant on-screen persona. Although his interpretation of the Joker didn’t match the dark and intense portrayals that came later, such as Heath Ledger’s in “The Dark Knight,” Romero’s performance set the stage for future versions of the iconic DC character. The classic “Batman” series from this decade is still cherished, with both Romero and West’s performances contributing significantly to the comic’s popularity on both the big and small screens.

4 Mark Hamill in Batman: The Animated Series (1992 – 1994), other projects

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

Hamill’s portrayal of the Joker started in the 1992 animated series “Batman: The Animated Series” and extended to subsequent spin-offs, video games, and movies. Hamill gained recognition for his acting skills, making him a sought-after voice actor for villainous characters. Hamill expressed on Twitter that he longed for a role that contrasted significantly with his beloved “Star Wars” character, Luke Skywalker. The Joker, the notorious mastermind of chaos, proved to be an unexpected and versatile gift from the realm of character acting.

Joker Is Hamill’s Iconic Voice Role

The Animated Series,” “Superman: The Animated Series,” “The New Batman Adventures,” and “Justice League.” He also did voiceovers for some parts of “Robot Chicken.” Additionally, he voiced the Joker in the 1993 film “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm” and the 2000 direct-to-video movie “Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker.” Hamill’s portrayal of the Joker in the animated adaptation of “Batman: The Killing Joke,” released in theaters for a brief period in 2016, earned him two Annie Award nominations.

3 Jack Nicholson in Batman (1989)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

In Tim Burton’s blockbuster film, Carl Grissom, portrayed by Jack Palance, rules over crime-ridden Gotham City as its ruthless kingpin. Enter Batman (Michael Keaton), a new vigilante determined to bring law and order. Grissom’s trusted confidant, Jack Napier (Jack Nicholson), is a violent and unstable man with questionable mental health. After a bitter dispute between the two, Grissom orders Napier’s arrest, leading him to plummet into a vat of chemicals. However, this supposed demise proves temporary as Napier emerges anew as The Joker, wreaking havoc and chaos in Gotham City.

A Career-Defining Performance From Nicholson

In 1989, the ominous portrayal of the Joker by Jack Nicholson first graced the screens in “Batman,” bringing in over $400 million globally at the box office. This role became a pivotal moment for Nicholson’s acting career and left critics impressed, with some even suggesting his performance outshone that of the Caped Crusader himself. The success of “Batman” then paved the way for the 1992 animated series, “Batman: The Animated Series,” where Mark Hamill took center stage as the menacing villain. However, Nicholson’s iconic interpretation of the Joker continued to dominate the live-action scene for years afterwards.

2 Joaquin Phoenix in Joker (2019)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

The latest live-action portrayal of Joker features Joaquin Phoenix as Arthur Fleck, a struggling clown with an unstable mental condition that causes him to laugh uncontrollably. With society pressuring him and his condition, life is particularly challenging for him. As time goes by, these struggles significantly impact Arthur’s behavior, leading him to adopt the infamous alter ego.

Phoenix Shines as The Joker

In a fresh take on the Batman saga, Todd Phillips’ 2019 movie explores the Joker’s backstory in a new and distinctive way compared to past installments. Despite sparking controversy due to its graphic violence and representation of mental health issues, Joaquin Phoenix’s captivating portrayal garnered critical acclaim. Like its predecessor, The Dark Knight, Joker surpassed the $1 billion mark in box office sales and amassed numerous accolades – including an Oscar for Best Actor awarded to Phoenix. Making history as the first live-action Batman film rated R by the Motion Picture Association, Joker thrived under this adults-only classification, granting Phoenix unbridled creativity and fully embodying today’s Joker character.

1 Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight (2008)

Best Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), RankedBest Joker Performances (Live-Action & Animated), Ranked

In the aftermath of the events from “Batman Begins,” unfolds the story of “The Dark Knight.” About a year later, Batman (Christian Bale), Lt. James Gordon (Gary Oldman), and the new District Attorney Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart) are making headway in their mission to clean up Gotham City by arresting its criminals. However, their progress is disrupted when a shadowy figure named “The Joker” (Heath Ledger) emerges in Gotham, bringing anarchy and mayhem. Batman’s battle against The Joker becomes a deeply personal one, compelling him to reevaluate all his beliefs and enhance his technology to put an end to the chaos.

A Career-Best Performance For Ledger

As a film enthusiast with a deep appreciation for cinematic art and a particular interest in groundbreaking productions, I have had the privilege of witnessing some truly exceptional films throughout my life. Among them is one that continues to leave an indelible mark on both the industry and me personally – a film that has been hailed as not only one of the best of its decade but also one of the greatest and most influential works in cinema history.

At the 81st Academy Awards, “The Dark Knight” earned eight nominations, and posthumously, Heath Ledger received the first of his two Oscars for portraying the Joker character. Although Phoenix’s interpretation of the Joker in 2019 was more prominent, it was Ledger who brought Nolan’s finest work to life with his fearless performance in “The Dark Knight.” When asked earlier about casting Ledger for the role, Nolan stated, “He had no boundaries.”

Read More

2024-07-21 03:04