‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Star Camilla Luddington on Ex-Writer Elisabeth Finch’s Betrayal: “It Sucks to Be a Part of the Story”

by

As I delve deeper into the heart-wrenching tale of Sarah Hayley Finch and her deceitful antics, I can’t help but feel a profound sense of empathy for those who were unfortunate enough to be ensnared in her web of lies. The experiences shared by Capshaw and Luddington, two talented actresses who found themselves unwittingly entangled in Finch’s story, highlight the devastating impact of gaslighting on one’s life and psyche.

Following the release of Peacock’s documentary on Elisabeth Finch earlier this month, actress Camilla Luddington has been asked to share her thoughts (even by the documentary’s directors and The Hollywood Reporter) regarding the former Grey’s Anatomy writer who was exposed for fabricating parts of her life story. However, Luddington, who has portrayed Dr. Jo Wilson on the popular ABC medical drama for 12 seasons, did not comment during the making of the documentary, nor has she done so since the release of “Anatomy of Lies” on October 15. Now, Luddington and her former co-star Jessica Capshaw are discussing their feelings about this experience on their shared podcast.

Capshaw, co-host of the Call It What It Is podcast and former Dr. Arizona Robbins actress on Grey’s for ten seasons, recalled, ‘I had heard that a documentary was being made, but it turned out to be after discovering that someone I regularly interacted with at Grey’s had fabricated her entire identity – who she claimed to be, events from her past.’ She emphasized, ‘It was an entirely different person, another story altogether.’

Luddington responded, ‘It’s terrifying when a person can deceive so effortlessly and convincingly that it’s hard to tell truth from falsehood.’ This individual had lied to us about having cancer, which is something one rarely expects anyone to fabricate.

Finch served as a leading writer and later co-executive producer on the TV show ‘Grey’s’ for eight seasons. However, it was revealed (through an email from her former partner, Jennifer Beyer, to Shonda Rhimes, the creator of ‘Grey’s’) that she had invented significant aspects of her personal life, which were often used as inspiration for various storylines.

The show “Anatomy of Lies” delves into several storylines, such as the potent 2019 episode “Silent All These Years,” inspired by Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony during Brett Kavanaugh’s Supreme Court confirmation hearing. This episode was followed by narrative threads related to Jo Finch, a character who fabricated numerous tales of trauma. In an interview with THR, the documentary’s directors revealed that the writer of this episode had a peculiar attachment to Jo Finch, as she herself wrote the story. Among other false narratives she created for Jo, she claimed that she had rare bone cancer, lost a kidney, underwent an abortion, and suffered from PTSD due to her connections with the 2018 Pittsburgh synagogue shooting.

In conversation with Capshaw, Luddington compared the situation to being a part of an unrecognized episode of the crime documentary show, Dateline. “Just as you watch these documentaries and think ‘I would have known they were lying,’ here I was living it,” she said on their Call It Liars podcast. “I had no idea. I really didn’t. And that’s what bothers me because then it makes you question your own instincts. ‘Why didn’t I see through this? How could I have believed that?’ I dislike this self-doubt it brings on.

Following Beyer’s contact with Rhimes, Finch faced an investigation by Shondaland and Disney, resulting in a temporary departure from Grey’s in March 2022. Shortly after this, Evgenia Peretz, co-director of Anatomy of Lies, published a two-part expose in Vanity Fair with Beyer’s assistance, revealing Finch’s longstanding fabrications. Since then, Finch has issued two apologies: one in a late 2022 interview with The Ankler and another on her now-private social media, expressing regret to her family and friends upon the release of Anatomy of Lies. However, Beyer, in a post on Facebook, dismissed this apology, stating that Finch has shown no genuine remorse for her actions towards Beyer or their children.

Regarding Finch, Capshaw stated, “Her truthfulness had never crossed my mind to doubt. The falsehoods she told were unimaginable to even suspect.” After discovering the facts, Capshaw admitted, “I felt somewhat fooled, thinking, ‘She was exceptionally convincing, because I believed her.’ However, I wasn’t in the position of the woman she married and saw a completely different life with her.

Capshaw and Luddington described Beyer’s (Finch’s ex-wife) situation as if she was living in a film.

Luddington mentioned, “I’m speaking up now because I was requested to share thoughts on this documentary – an unusual feeling to see myself portrayed like that. As for discussing my experiences working with a specific individual on set, I prefer not to delve into it. The truth is, it’s challenging for me to… you can imagine… with this person. What troubles me most is that it prompts you to reconsider every little detail.

Afterward, Luddington recounted an untold experience from her initial visit to Hawaii – a journey she was thrilled about because it marked an affordable vacation for her, which she embarked on alongside her spouse-to-be, Matthew Alan – and it so happened that Finch made an appearance, three days into her stay, at the bar of the hotel where she was residing in Kauai, as he too was on holiday with someone else.

“I remember thinking it was the most random coincidence,” said Luddington. “Then you start to think back about, ‘Who did I tell?’ I had told so many people where I was going, I’m sure I would have told her. And, is there a world in which she just happened to be on vacation at that hotel with me in Kauai? Sure. That happens, people run into each other. But I don’t like the now questioning and going back and reevaluating all those things.”

Later on, Capshaw inquired, “Did she identify herself as Jo Wilson when checking in?” This query alluded to Finch’s admission into her treatment center and her introduction to Beyer using the name “Jo,” a detail discussed in the novel “Anatomy of Lies.” Capshaw added, “I wholeheartedly trusted everything she said. There wasn’t a single moment of doubt.” Then, Capshaw went on to recall, “When I departed from [Grey’s], she sought me out. We ended up having an extended conversation outside my trailer because she was upset that I was leaving and wanted to talk about it. … What’s real, and what isn’t?

Luddington expressed her discomfort about how the Grey’s family seemed too deeply involved in Finch’s narrative. She stated, “I didn’t appreciate feeling like someone as questionable as that was within our circle without really sensing any authenticity from them myself. It’s just unsettling and nothing about it feels right.” She added, “It’s frustrating to be a part of someone else’s story. It’s uncomfortable being connected to such narratives.

The main characters from “Grey’s” chose to discuss this topic on their podcast to help those who may have experienced similar circumstances, a sentiment shared by the directors of “Anatomy of Lies,” explaining their motivation behind adapting Beyer’s story for television.

Peretz expressed great satisfaction in witnessing Beyer’s healing journey since the documentary was released, noting that it wasn’t just for her benefit. They aimed to reach a broad audience who have experienced deep betrayal, deception, or a sudden realization that the person they trusted isn’t who they thought. This feeling of being manipulated, often referred to as gaslighting, is quite common, and they hope those who can relate will find comfort knowing they aren’t alone. Instead of feeling foolish, they want them to understand it’s a common human experience.

David Schisgall, her fellow director and husband, commented, “Individuals exploited in such a manner tend to be highly empathetic. It could be said that the larger one’s compassion, the more susceptible they become to experiences like these.

Read More

2024-10-30 17:55