As someone who has spent a good chunk of my life surrounded by the vibrant and complex tapestry that is Mormon culture, I found “Heretic” to be a fascinating and well-researched exploration of its nuances. The filmmakers clearly put in the effort to understand the intricacies of the faith, and it shows in every frame.
The recently launched movie titled “Heretic” is another impressive production from A24, a studio recognized for its high-quality films that have earned both critical and commercial success. Released in theaters on November 8th this year, it has already gathered significant attention and praise. Currently standing at 91% on RottenTomatoes and 71% on Metacritic, this film is rapidly establishing itself as an engaging and captivating thriller.
From a passionate viewer’s perspective, the film I’m referring to features Hugh Grant, Sophie Thatcher, and Chloe East in the starring roles. This captivating production was masterfully penned and directed by the duo, Scott Beck and Bryan Woods. The plot revolves around two young Mormon missionaries who find themselves ensnared by a charming yet menacing individual with dark motives.
What ‘Heretic’ Gets Right
The film introduces its central figures, Sister Paxton and Sister Barnes, portrayed by Chloe East and Sophie Thatcher. These two characters serve as our guides into Mormonism and missionary work. If the writers aimed for authenticity in depicting the Mormon faith, these were the characters they had to get spot-on. The actresses’ portrayals of these complex and captivating characters are superb, really breathing life into them.
In my perspective, I embody a certain innocence and fervor, much like what others may associate with a Mormon missionary – I’m cheerful, amiable, and deeply devoted to my beliefs. Contrasting me is Sister Barnes, who appears more skeptical and prudent. She’s the one who initially senses that something isn’t quite right about Mr. Reed, portrayed by Hugh Grant, and the peculiar predicament we find ourselves in at his residence.
Mr. Reed’s Lie Is Well Thought-Out
Typically, sister missionaries wouldn’t be allowed to enter a home alone with just a man present, mainly due to safety concerns. So, Mr. Reed’s trick of pretending his wife was in another room and would soon join them, thus convincing Sister Paxton and Sister Barnes to come in, is quite clever. In fact, it was the only way that sister missionaries could enter a home with a man they didn’t know.
It’s also plausible that the Sisters might not scrutinize matters too deeply or harbor suspicion initially because they are elated to find someone who is open to their evangelism. This makes Mr. Reed an ideal candidate for setting a trap, as he appears not just willing but enthusiastic about engaging with them – something Mormon missionaries don’t always encounter.
Mormon Missionaries Really Are Put in Dangerous Situations
Beck and Woods effectively addressed the safety considerations for missionaries in their film, an issue that applies to both male and female missionaries but is particularly pertinent for Sister Missionaries. Mormon missionaries are often tasked with visiting homes of strangers, occasionally extending into evening hours up until 9 PM.
The nature of their assignment exposes them to potential perils, yet they are not always equipped with prior knowledge on how to handle such risks. They harbor a strong faith which assures them that “the divine presence” or God will protect them, ensuring their safety and well-being. This portrayal of the Sisters’ unawareness, lack of preparation, and reliance on divine intervention aligns with real-life experiences.
Sister Barnes and Sister Paxton
The design of the costumes for the main characters closely resembles what real-life female missionaries might wear and follows the dress code typically enforced by Mormon churches during proselytizing. Notably, the film subtly emphasizes this Mormon fashion, even touching upon the unique garments like temple garments that are significant within the faith. As Mr. Reed notes during his efforts to shake their beliefs, the church exerts considerable influence over a Mormon’s life, extending down to what they wear, such as their undergarments.
It’s interesting to point out that Chloe East and Sophie Thatcher, who play the missionaries in the film, grew up as Mormons. Although they no longer identify as Mormon, their upbringing in this religion has left a lasting impact on them. For instance, East seems to maintain some ties with it through her acquaintances. The decision to cast ex-Mormons for these roles appears purposeful and was likely a well-thought-out choice by the casting team.
What ‘Heretic’ Got Wrong
Beck and Woods aren’t Mormons themselves or brought up in the faith, yet they’ve conducted thorough research and consulted with individuals who have personal knowledge about Mormonism. However, there were a few points in their work that might be seen as inaccuracies. This is quite common in realistic fiction, where achieving absolute accuracy can be challenging, and sometimes artistic license must be taken to create the most compelling narrative.
As a film enthusiast, let me put it this way: If a fellow like Mr. Reed feigns an interest in the church, as he does, and requests a visit from missionaries, they might be redirected to the “elders,” or male missionaries. Therefore, it’s quite plausible that in actuality, a character such as Mr. Reed would never have Sister Missionaries knocking on his door, ready for any traps he might have set up.
It’s worth noting that while missionaries typically work in pairs or small groups, there’s a scene showing a single male missionary visiting Mr. Reed’s house out of concern for the sisters. However, this scenario seems to contradict reality as missionaries rarely go alone.
How the Church Has Responded
In essence, these are minor, insignificant flaws in the overall storyline, but the movie portrays Mormonism remarkably accurately, down to every detail. There’s no hint of accidental or haphazard elements; everything appears to have been carefully considered and planned.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has issued a statement criticizing the movie, asserting that its portrayal of Mormonism and Mormon missionaries is incorrect and disrespectful. Moreover, they argue that the movie encourages violence against women, particularly those who practice their faith. However, there are other Mormons, including Chloe East, who hold a different view and consider the film to be a nuanced and truthful depiction.
As someone intrigued by the subject, I found Mormonism’s portrayal in the movie Heretic to be both respectful and well-balanced, allowing for a diverse range of interpretations. Ultimately, the experience is personal and varies among individuals. Nonetheless, I strongly recommend watching Heretic as it offers an opportunity to shape your own understanding about this fascinating topic.
Heretic is currently in theaters.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-11-21 05:03