How Squid Game’s Transgender Character Succeeded Where Emilia Pérez Failed Me As A Queer Person

by

Over the last several years, there has been much discussion about the significance of representation in media, including the debate over LGBT+ actors portraying queer characters and the manner in which these stories are presented. A significant aspect of this conversation is how these narratives unfold, and I am particularly invested in this topic as a member of the LGBT+ community. In my opinion, the transgender character from Squid Game achieved success where Emilia Pérez fell short for me in a crucial way.

The two projects mentioned earlier are available on Netflix for streaming, each showcasing distinct trans characters. However, the portrayal of Emilia Pérez left me uneasy, particularly the storyline where she deceived her spouse and children by pretending to be a long-lost relative. This narrative trope, which suggests that trans individuals are untrustworthy, is a harmful stereotype that the community has been grappling with for years. It’s disheartening to see this kind of story perpetuated even by an award-winning production, and it’s understandable why some members of the LGBT+ community have found it difficult to accept.

Standing in contrast, we have Park Sung-hoon portraying Cho Hyun-ju from the revamped second season of “Squid Game”. Although it’s unfortunate that a trans Korean actress wasn’t given this role (a chance missed for transgender performers), Player 120 authentically embodies their character and is both relatable and trustworthy within the grim context of the games. Moreover, they have gained support from other contestants who are struggling to earn money and navigate through the events portrayed in the widely-acclaimed series.

In the eagerly anticipated third season of “Squid Game,” viewers will discover if Cho Hyun-ju survives, but my feelings about this character contrast sharply with those I had for Emilia Pérez. The talented actress Karla Sofía Gascón portrayed the lead role in the movie musical exceptionally well, and she’s garnering well-deserved praise during this Awards Season. However, my problem lies not with her performance but rather with the film’s script and the central struggle revolving around her reunion with her family.

Due to Emilia Pérez’s outstanding performance at the Golden Globe Awards, which earned her the Best Musical award over Wicked, there has been a lot of online analysis and debate regarding the daring aspects of the production. Besides the portrayal of its title character, the musical’s songs have sparked controversy, with a specific number titled “La vaginoplastia” being particularly criticized. This song discusses the surgeries Emilia will undergo during her transition process.

While I personally think it’s ideal for transgender characters to be portrayed by transgender actors, I found Cho Hyun-ju’s story in “Squid Game” more relatable and comfortable than Emilia Pérez’s character. However, both Squid Game and the movie featuring Emilia are currently available on Netflix, allowing viewers to make their own choices. In the meantime, take a look at the 2025 movie release schedule to help you plan your annual movie adventures.

Read More

2025-01-16 01:37