I Just Finished Watching Attack On Titan, And Now I Have A Major Concern For The Live-Action Movie

by

I’ve just recently finished watching “Attack On Titan” after being behind by about two years, and I must say it’s one of the greatest anime ever made, according to many fans, and I concur with that assessment. Given my admiration for the series, I would be thrilled if director Andy Muschietti took charge of a live-action film adaptation, but now, I have significant reservations about it.

As a devoted cinephile, I can’t help but express my apprehension over the upcoming adaptation of “Attack on Titan” that won’t grace our cinemas until 2025. While I applaud Hollywood for venturing into high-budget anime adaptations, this particular venture seems like a formidable challenge, teetering on the edge of ambition and overreach.

For those uninitiated with the series who wish to approach the movie without prior knowledge potentially spoiling their experience, let me offer a summary that steers clear of intricate story details. Picture a world where gigantic humanoid creatures known as Titans pose an existential threat to humanity. The story follows a group of brave humans fighting back against these monstrous invaders using the city walls for protection and innovative combat techniques. It’s a thrilling blend of action, suspense, and emotion that has captivated audiences worldwide. So, if you’re ready to experience this epic tale on the big screen, mark your calendars for 2025!

Attack On Titan’s Story Can’t Be Covered In A Single Movie

Initially, when Attack On Titan debuted, I stopped following the show after completing Season 1. However, upon learning that a film was in production, I felt quite excited, thinking “It shouldn’t be difficult to create a movie about humans battling Titans.” Fast forward twelve years later, and I have finally completed the series, realizing now that it will indeed prove challenging.

In the series “Attack on Titan”, each story arc becomes increasingly complex and thrilling, making it seem like a modernized version of “Jack and the Beanstalk” on performance-enhancing substances. However, if you haven’t seen it, this comparison might sound absurd. Yet, those who have watched can attest to its transformation into something more akin to Netflix’s “House of Cards”.

It’s common knowledge that an attempt at a live-action film was made in Japan, and it received harsh criticism for straying from the main storyline. I concur that the Attack on Titan (AOT) narrative should remain unchanged in its American adaptation. However, I am unsure of how this can be achieved. Nonetheless, it’s possible to create a compelling plot by condensing Season 1 into less than 3 hours.

The narrative of Attack on Titan is so rich that it may struggle to be fully appreciated in just one live-action movie. Fans of the anime are clamoring for an epic multi-film saga, but it remains uncertain whether the general public will flock to see it. While Attack on Titan does have a dedicated fanbase, its success as a film franchise might depend heavily on strong box office performance, given that new intellectual properties often face challenges in this area.

There Are Parts Of The Story That Need To Be In The First Movie, But Will Only Make Sense Much Later

To avoid spoiling the story for those who haven’t seen it, I won’t discuss the reasons why a film adaptation of “Attack on Titan” might pose challenges, but fans of the anime are probably aware of what I mean. Essentially, this series has a way of presenting information and major plot points that can be missed upon first watch, even in the earliest episodes. So, one may wonder if these subtle hints will remain in the new interpretation of the universe.

If there’s a possibility or a proposal for the anime “Attack on Titan” to be expanded into multiple movies, it’s almost certain. Leaving out such hints might frustrate dedicated fans, but it would create a more intriguing experience for newcomers who discover key plot points at a later stage. However, at this point, we’ve only been informed about one movie being in production. A report from Inside The Magic suggested that Andy Muschietti stepped down from the project in November of 2023, but without any official confirmation, I find it hard to believe this is accurate.

As a devoted cinephile, I must express my concerns about the potential of “Attack on Titan” being reimagined as a standalone adventure. If they choose to alter the storyline significantly, it might lead to an outcome similar to what we witnessed with other anime adaptations like “Avatar: The Last Airbender” on the silver screen – a disastrous reception from fans.

In my view, deviating from the source material could potentially jeopardize the success of the live-action remake and ultimately drive away the loyal fanbase who cherish the original narrative. After all, it’s the authenticity and faithfulness to the source material that keeps us coming back for more.

I Fear The Reason Anime Fans Love Attack On Titan Will Be What Turns The Mainstream Off By It

I’m an individual who spent my childhood years immersed in the classic 80s and 90s anime series, and still follow some modern ones like “One Piece”. However, it wasn’t until I watched the entire “Attack On Titan” series myself that I truly grasped why so many people were captivated by it. My main concern is that a large portion of the global audience who are interested in this movie might view it as primarily about humans fighting Titans. If they expect the plot to remain at that level, they may be disappointed when the storyline develops into something more complex, potentially deterring many viewers.

I regret to say that I believe feature films tend not to do justice to manga and anime, as they struggle to capture the intricacies of a storyline like Eren Yeager’s journey or the awesomeness of one of popular culture’s most formidable female characters. It’s difficult for the average viewer to fully appreciate these aspects in a film format.

The climax carries a significant and impactful message after 94 episodes, one that strikes powerfully. Frankly, if the rumors are true about the Attack on Titan movie losing its director and being in uncertain waters, I wouldn’t be too disappointed. To be honest, I prefer the concept to remain unused than to be executed poorly. I can only hope that whoever takes charge of it has a clear understanding of what they’re dealing with.

The reimagining of “Attack On Titan” is currently under development, but we’re still unclear about its release date. I can only cross my fingers that when we receive updates, the project turns out to be as competently handled as Netflix has managed with their adaptation of “One Piece”.

Read More

2025-01-15 00:38