I Just Heard The Mean Girls Theory About Janis Ian And The Lesbian Vs Lebanese Mix-Up, And I Have Some Thoughts

by

In the world of “Mean Girls,” discussions continue to thrive, particularly regarding Lindsay Lohan’s references and the comparison of the film’s plot to a religious clique. However, what intrigues me is the debate surrounding Janis Ian and the ambiguous line about being Lesbian or Lebanese. The Tina Fey-directed “Mean Girls” is often hailed as one of the top high school movies, filled with clever and biting humor, such as the Lesbian vs Lebanese joke. As a dedicated fan of both Tina Fey and “Mean Girls,” I’d like to share some thoughts on the use of that gag in the iconic and endlessly quotable Mean Girls.

If you’re familiar with Tina Fey, you’d know she’s no laughing matter when it comes to writing or comedy. This is why the popular theory about the mix-up between “Lesbian” and “Lebanese” in the movie “Mean Girls” emerged. In essence, the theory suggests that Regina mistakenly took Janis to be a lesbian due to a rumor she spread. Later on, when Janis reveals that she’s Lebanese, it seems as though Regina may have confused the two terms.

Reddit users have been chatting about a significant line delivered by Regina George concerning Janis Ian, a line that’s part of a hilarious inside joke for fans. Many are diving deep into the conversation to clarify any confusion and highlight how the Lesbian-Lebanese aspect plays a crucial role in the world of Mean Girls. DebateObjective2787 pointed out that this joke becomes more nuanced as the movie progresses, adding that it’s a common trope often seen in media.

In the closing moments of the movie, Janice casually reveals her Lebanese heritage when conversing with Kevin G. There’s a persistent humor trope in media where people misunderstand being Lebanese for being a lesbian. Both The Golden Girls and Glee have employed comparable comedic devices.

In the discussion at hand, Regina confides in Cady about her former friendship with Janis, which dates back to their days in middle school. However, their bond changed when Regina’s character began dating her first boyfriend. This change sparked an obsession within Janis to discover the location of the head Plastic, causing Regina to exclude Janis from an upcoming all-girl birthday pool party she was hosting. You can watch the scene below for more context:

In my opinion, that poignant flashback of our former friendship plays a crucial role in the movie that mirrors the book’s essence flawlessly. It offers viewers an understanding of the stark contrast between Cady’s social spheres and reveals why the once inseparable duo ultimately drifted apart. This pivotal scene not only exposes Regina’s insincerity but also underscores Janis’ unwavering loyalty. Subtly, it lays the foundation for the Lesbian vs Lebanese theory that unfolds later on in the story. Although we don’t actually witness George’s misunderstanding of those two words, the stage is effectively set, and the pieces fall into place once you hear Janis mention she’s Lebanese at the dance.

In a slightly different rendition, I’d say: “Though the Mark Waters-directed movie subtly touches upon this theme, it isn’t entirely new to me or fellow enthusiasts. As MarinaAndTheDragons pointed out, other shows have also toyed with the concept of word mix-ups, as evidenced by the exchange between the Golden Girls.

…In a 1986 episode of The Golden Girls, the humor is flipped in this manner:
Sophia says, “Let me tell you something, Jean, you’re a lesbian.”
Blanche replies, “What’s so amusing about that?”
Sophia questions, “You’re not taken aback by it?”
Blanche responds, “Well, I’ve never met one personally, but isn’t Danny Thomas?”
Dorothy clarifies, “Not Lebanese, Blanche. Lesbian.

Although they’re not frequently encountered, I’d wager that they’re nowhere near as cleverly conceived as Tina Fey’s masterpieces. To be honest, the underlying structure and punchline might seem somewhat predictable, but Tina Fey breathed fresh life into it. Instead of Regina and Cady, the joke is subtly unveiled to two other characters. Towards the end, Janis casually reveals she’s Lebanese while dancing with Kevin G, a moment that, if you share my perspective, echoes the distinctive humor of Tina Fey’s work on 30 Rock.

If you’re curious, Fey was also involved with the entertaining musical adaptation of “Mean Girls” released recently. Unlike the movie-Broadway-musical, Fey didn’t include the original joke but replaced it with a different subplot. In this new production, her character is rumored to be Pyro (the story reveals she accidentally set fire to a plush toy which led to other items catching fire), rather than a possible lesbian as previously suggested. Instead, in this film, she openly identifies as queer. This alteration subtly shifts the dynamic between the two antagonists, but it’s not in a negative way.

It’s delightful to observe fans deciphering the Janis Ian “Mean Girls” joke, showcasing how Tina Fey’s timeless wit continues to captivate audiences and spark intrigue among new admirers.

Read More

2025-01-31 03:07