‘Idiotka’ Review: Reality TV Satire and Heartwarming Family Dramedy Collide in a Messy but Winning Directorial Debut

by

In the movie “Idiotka,” Margarita (Anna Baryshnikov) describes her style as a blend of antiquated charm and thrift store finds, saying, “My aesthetic is a mix of old-world charm and flea market treasures.” At five, she’s milking a cow, but by 5:10, she’s off to ballet. She’s always on the lookout for a good deal.

Regarding its style, it’s nonsensical yet captivatingly quirky; as an illustration of a hypothetical wearer, it’s a jumble of words, but in a strange way, it perfectly embodies “Idiotka“. Nastasya Popov’s first directorial effort, the feature film, is indeed chaotic, a mix of conflicting moods and opposing thoughts. However, despite its messiness, it manages to win you over with its vibrant character.

The style it portrays is absurdly charming yet nonsensical; if you imagine the wearer, it’s a confused mix of words, but somehow, it encapsulates “Idiotka” perfectly. Nastasya Popov’s debut film as a writer-director might seem chaotic with its clashing tones and contradictory ideas, but there’s something about its energy that draws you in and keeps you captivated.

Initially, I found myself drawn into “Idiotka” as a satire of a specific genre devoid of heart. In the opening moments, the protagonist Margarita justifies her appearance due to a submission for a reality show aimed at underprivileged fashion designers. The focus here is on the ‘underprivileged’ aspect. Contestants are required to submit their tax documents to demonstrate their financial struggles to meet eligibility criteria. The duo of host Oliver (Owen Theiele) and producer Nicol (Camila Mendes), who exudes an icy charm, seeks individuals with “lives worth peeling back” – a glossy euphemism for those who possess heart-wrenching personal narratives.

As a passionate admirer, I find myself standing in Margarita’s shoes, juggling my artistic aspirations with the concerns of my Russian and Ukrainian Jewish immigrant family – grandma Gita (Galina Jovovich), brother Nerses (Nerses Stamos), and dad Samuel (Mark Ivanir). They’re naturally cautious about the show’s emphasis on hardship, but faced with the stark reality of being six months behind on our minuscule West Hollywood apartment rent, they can hardly fault me for chasing a potential $100,000 prize. So, I stride into an audition where Nicol and Oliver seem intrigued by Samuel’s recent prison release or curious about my emotional state. If I’m teetering on the edge, so much the better: “We love unhinged,” Nicol quips nonchalantly.

Popov possesses an innate ability to discern the insincere empathy often found in show business, and “Idiotka” serves as a critique of how narratives about marginalization and pain are turned into a mass-market friendly “authenticity.” Instead of displaying their individual styles, Margarita and other contestants like Yeezy-inspired Jung-soo (Jake Choi) and modernist Malcolm (Shaun J. Brown), are more about showcasing their unique cultural backgrounds. At a certain point, the term “deeply ethnic” is used as a high praise.

During interviews, Margarita is subtly prompted to appear more vulnerable. Behind the scenes, Nicol suggests she shares videos of her personal life, with the most awkward moments being preferred. From Nicol’s perspective, this is all just “excellent content.” The cost to Margarita and her family in exposing their private struggles for public entertainment, or whether these scenes accurately portray their real-life experiences, seems irrelevant compared to how effectively it can be presented to the audience.

As a gamer, I found myself grappling with the shift in tone during “Idiotka’s” industry satire. The movie, initially brimming with sharp critique, morphed into a heartwarming family drama towards its latter half. This sudden change felt as jarring and unpredictable as sorting through a laundry hamper that seems to have been slightly curated.

Margarita’s character is like a video game boss, filled with contradictions. One moment she’s surrounded by caricatures reminiscent of a life coach, who dresses just like Julia Fox and is played by her too; the next, she’s connecting with her dad, sharing his dreams that echo those from “Shawshank” without any hint of redemption.

In the beginning, it’s tough to tell whether Margarita is delusional or driven, cynical or sincere. It’s a game of guessing, and I found myself second-guessing my assumptions throughout.

Despite being somewhat lackluster when it comes to pushing itself to its full potential, surprisingly, Idiotka’s softer aspects prove to be just as effective. Popov skillfully captures the gentle camaraderie that permeates throughout the family, even during tense moments, and the cast exhibits a delightful rapport and ease with one another.

Baryshnikov effortlessly transitions between quirky humor and sincere emotion, making an unusual blend feel almost harmonious. Jovovich shines as Gita, whose vibrant character is outdone only by her immense compassion. Moreover, Ivanir gives a moving portrayal to the most dramatically intense role in the story, conveying Samuel’s remorse but also his genuine pride and happiness in his daughter. Together, they build an environment that feels welcoming and secure, as if you’ve entered a place where love and empathy abound. Despite the fact that those providing it may be flawed and argumentative, or appear to argue frequently among themselves.

Just like with the film “Idiotka,” it often seems to struggle with its own identity. It’s unclear whether it’s fully committed to its cultural critique, if it should be more exaggerated or realistic, and if it should portray a cynical or optimistic tone at different points. However, one thing that’s consistently clear is that it comes from a unique perspective, brimming with exciting possibilities.

Read More

2025-03-13 23:54