MetaMask dev Consensys: SEC claims unsupported in law

As a seasoned analyst with over two decades of experience in the financial industry, I find myself closely watching this ongoing saga between Consensys and the SEC. My personal perspective is that this battle is not just about one company or regulatory agency but rather a testament to the evolving nature of technology and its relationship with traditional regulations.


ConsenSys, a developer specializing in Ethereum infrastructure, has submitted a rebuttal to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s accusations of violating federal securities laws. This response further increases the number of legal actions it has taken against the regulatory body.

Previously, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) alleged that ConsenSys’ cryptocurrency wallet, MetaMask, functioned without proper registration as a broker and issuer of securities.

ConsenSys firmly denied the charges made by the SEC, expressing criticism towards the agency and its head, Gary Gensler, for what they deemed as an unconstitutional assault on the decentralized finance sector. Their response filed in court reiterated their position and displeasure with the SEC’s legal action against them.

This action is just the latest step in the SEC’s recent campaign to seize control over the future of blockchains and cryptocurrency, one of the fastest-growing and most innovative technologies in the world… The SEC’s attempt to impose its regulatory authority on this technology and insert itself into this crypto architecture is unsupported in the law — its claims must fail.

Consensys response to SEC suit

Prior to being targeted by an SEC investigation, Lubin’s firm had previously taken legal action against the SEC regarding their Ethereum (ETH) investigation. Subsequently, the SEC ended their inquiry and filed a lawsuit against the creator of MetaMask. The SEC claims that MetaMask was involved in unlawful securities trading and that its staking service contravened financial regulations.

Consensys has filed a lawsuit against the regulator to clarify if the SEC holds jurisdiction under the current law. Bill Hughes, representing Consensys, disclosed that U.S. Judge O’Connor has fast-tracked the trial schedule for this case.

In the meantime, CEO Joseph Lubin disclosed that staff reductions were necessary due to challenges in regulation and broader economic conditions. As a result, ConsenSys cut its team size by 20%.

Under scrutiny from SEC lawsuits, some businesses might view the upcoming U.S. elections as an opportunity. Notably, digital asset firms have contributed more than $190 million to political action committees (PACs) that focus on cryptocurrency, outspending all other industries in this area.

If Donald Trump, the Republican candidate, is elected in 2024, he has said he plans to remove Gary Gensler as the head of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in January 2025. In case there’s a standstill at the commission, SEC legal actions might slow down temporarily. However, if Democrat Kamala Harris wins the election, Gensler could remain in his position until 2026.

Read More

2024-11-02 00:20