Moana 2’s Songwriters Have Heard The Criticisms And They Did Not Mince Words In Their Response

by

As a long-time enthusiast of animated films and a proud parent of two energetic kids, I must say that I’ve been following the buzz around Moana 2 with great interest. The original film was a delightful surprise, and I was eager to see how they would expand on the story and music for the sequel.

When examining the preliminary box office earnings for “Moana 2” in 2024, it’s clear that this late addition to the year’s films is already leaving an impression within its initial release period. However, some critics argue that the songs in “Moana 2” don’t quite measure up to Lin-Manuel Miranda’s music from the 2016 version. Unfazed by this critique, the songwriting duo Barlow and Bear have confidently responded with a firm rebuttal, using direct language to defend their work.

How Moana 2’s Songwriters Have Defended Their Song Contributions

In her conversation with Variety, songwriter Abigail Barlow directly tackled the issue and provided a straightforward response to alleviate any initial doubts about the music. At the beginning of their discussion, she swiftly diverted focus from worries by making this assertion at the forefront.

Give it a month, all the kids will be singing it, and you’ll be tired of it.

The issue regarding Barlow and Bear’s songs in Moana 2 became apparent swiftly, with their critical reception being one of the early indications. It was clear that Abigail Barlow, along with her songwriting partner Emily Bear, had given some thought to the potential response to their work before releasing the Disney+ series adaptation of Moana.

During an interview with Sarah El-Mahmoud, the duo recounted Dwayne Johnson’s response to “Can I Get A Chee Hoo?” shifting from doubt to enthusiastic endorsement. Simultaneously, internet fan reactions show a recurring wave of both praise and critique.

What People Have Been Saying About Moana 2’s Songs

At TopMob, we’re not exempt from the critique surrounding Disney’s recent blockbuster hit. Our critic, Corey Chichizola, even noticed the absence of Lin Manuel-Miranda’s influence in his review of Moana 2, and he presents a persuasive case for it.

On social media, opinions about these melodies seem to be divided. Here’s a sampling of some comments that delve into the musical aspect:

  • “The music was solid, but going from Lin Manuel Miranda songs in the original to non LMM songs in the sequel was very noticeable.” – @ATXsantucci
  • “… I liked the songs a lot (especially Beyond!)” – @starsofthestory
  • “Looking up who made the Moana 2 songs no one likes and saw exactly what I expected” – @Hey_Brian
  • “The musical numbers aren’t as good and the journey isn’t as compelling but they singin the fuck outta them songs & sailing the fuck outta that boat; not mad MOANA 2 gives the kids what they want.” – @VyceVictus
  • “I don’t get why people are saying the Moana 2 songs are awful? They’re not, they’re just not as good as the Moana 1 songs” – @DiamondSpiderP

One key insight from our chat about the music in Moana is likely the closing remark. Just because Lin-Manuel Miranda and Bear and Barlow are composers, it doesn’t mean that their creative processes are similar. Transitioning from one to the other should not be perceived as a continuous artistic journey.

A fresh team brings fresh abilities, and just as Abigail Barlow suggested, it’ll be the young audience who ultimately shape the musical legacy of Moana 2‘s soundtrack. Over time, parents around the globe will pass this message on to us all.

Right now, “Moana 2” is setting sail into the unknown in cinemas, and if you get the opportunity, I recommend checking out our review of how the sequel stacks up in 3D/4DX. If you’d like to revisit the adventure that brought us into the vibrant world of Disney’s heroine Moana, your best bet is to subscribe to Disney+ and hop on board for this exciting voyage.

Read More

2024-12-06 19:38