Nicolas Cage’s Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian Nightmare

Nicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian Nightmare

Quick Links

  • Color Out of Space Plot and Cast
  • An Impressively Creative Lovecraft Adaptation
  • Why Color Out of Space Is So Underrated
  • Where to Watch Color Out of Space

As a lifelong fan of Lovecraft and his cosmic horror tales, I was both excited and apprehensive when I heard about the release of “Color Out of Space.” Having read numerous adaptations that failed to capture the essence of Lovecraft’s work, I approached this film with a healthy dose of skepticism.


Nicolas Cage’s film career has been nothing short of fascinating, full of surprises and charm. After a ten-year span with average roles, he experienced an impressive comeback. Cage has amassed numerous accolades from both mainstream successes and cult favorites. Notably, in the last decade, the horror genre has embraced him warmly. From portraying the animatronic killer in Willy’s Wonderland to his captivating performance in Longlegs, Cage has left an indelible mark on horror fans.

Despite gaining recognition for his horror roles, two films have managed to escape the spotlight; one of them is “Color Out of Space” by Nicolas Cage. In this analysis, we delve into the Lovecraftian terror of “Color Out of Space,” highlight reasons to watch it, and explore why Cage’s performance in this film is often overlooked.

Color Out of Space Plot and Cast

On their tranquil farm in Massachusetts, the Gardner family enjoys a peaceful life. But their serenity is shattered when an unusual meteor lands on their property, releasing a strange hue that contaminates their land and water. The impact results in drastic transformations of their animals and crops. Soon enough, the family members undergo horrifying changes themselves, leading to erratic behavior. Among them is Nathan (Nicolas Cage), who experiences the most severe alterations, forcing the rest of the family to grapple with his escalating aggression and grotesque physical mutations.

In Arkham, they shared a chilling tale with me, given its rich history of witch lore, I assumed the evil spoke of was an ancient whisper passed down through generations. However, upon witnessing the ominous westward expanse of glens and slopes firsthand, my wonder shifted, leaving me captivated by its own enigmatic allure as Ward Phillips.

I’m a big fan of Nicolas Cage, and last year, I was thrilled to see him take on the role of Nathan, the patriarch of a family in a new film. This role was particularly special for me because it followed what many consider to be Cage’s impressive comeback in the critically acclaimed horror movie “Mandy.” Joining him in this project is the talented Joely Richardson, who plays Theresa, the mother of our on-screen family. I’ve long admired her work, especially from her time on “Nip/Tuck,” where she brilliantly portrayed Julia McNamara.

Richard Stanley took the helm in directing the film. Adored by cult movie enthusiasts, Stanley is known for his films “Dust Devil” and “Hardware,” though his notoriety stems from the ill-fated production of “The Island of Dr. Moreau” in 1996 (Morbidly Beautiful). After a hiatus of more than twenty years, “Color Out of Space” marked Stanley’s comeback as a director, with his previous narrative project being “Dust Devil” from 1992. The movie was inspired by the writings of renowned horror author H.P. Lovecraft.

An Impressively Creative Lovecraft Adaptation

Nicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian NightmareNicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian NightmareNicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian Nightmare

When considering Lovecraft’s work on film, some movies come to mind. For instance, there’s the exaggerated chaos and gore in “Re-Animator” and the dark, gothic tale of an ancient deity awakening in “The Call of Cthulhu” from 2005. However, “Color Out of Space,” which combines elements of Lovecraft’s Mythos and Dream Cycle, presents a distinctive mix of cosmic and metaphysical terror. This complex amalgamation makes the adaptation of an already intricate author even more demanding.

“The impact on this location defies explanation by human science. It was like a hue from realms beyond our comprehension. A harbinger from dimensions that leave us bewildered and speechless, revealing unfathomable expanses before us with an overwhelming intensity.” (Elliot Knight as Ward Phillips)

Although Richard Stanley highlighted various elements that draw us to Lovecraft’s work, he effectively conveyed the idea of “a color beyond human understanding” in a convincing manner. Nevertheless, Lovecraft’s original pieces are notoriously challenging to adapt authentically. In “Color Out of Space,” Stanley incorporates plenty of grisly and disturbing visual effects to keep horror enthusiasts on edge. Thus, this adaptation stands out as one of the most successful in capturing the essence of Lovecraft’s chilling tales.

Why Color Out of Space Is So Underrated

Nicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian NightmareNicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian NightmareNicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian Nightmare

At this stage in his acting career, Nicolas Cage had successfully returned to the horror genre with Panos Cosmatos’s film “Mandy.” This movie, which drew inspiration from H.P. Lovecraft’s terror, received significant acclaim. However, “Color Out of Space,” another horror film featuring Cage, did not receive as much attention. By checking the ratings on Letterboxd, you can see that over 220,000 users have rated “Mandy” while around 113,000 have evaluated “Color Out of Space.” Both movies have comparable ratings, with 3.6 for “Mandy” and 3.2 for “Color Out of Space.” Additionally, they both received positive reviews from critics, with a fresh score of 90% for “Mandy” and 86% for “Color Out of Space.”

As a longtime horror movie enthusiast and film critic, I have seen my fair share of critically acclaimed films that didn’t quite live up to the hype for me. However, there are instances where a movie defies expectations and leaves an indelible mark on me, like in the case of “Mandy.” Despite receiving a limited theatrical release similar to “Color Out of Space,” the buzz surrounding “Mandy” was palpable.

It’s regrettable that Nicolas Cage’s exceptional acting in “Color Out of Space” is overshadowed by the film’s other aspects. Known for his unique portrayals, Cage excels as an unconventional, sometimes quirky, paternal figure who transforms into a chaotic being. This can be observed in films like “Mandy,” “Mom and Dad,” and “Willy’s Wonderland.” In “Color Out of Space,” he masterfully brings this character to life, transitioning from a loving father to an unrestrained monster. For devotees of Nicolas Cage’s horror performances, “Color Out of Space” stands out as one of his finest works.

Where to Watch Color Out of Space

Nicolas Cage's Most Underrated Horror Is a Lovecraftian Nightmare

As a huge fan of horror films and the works of H.P. Lovecraft, I strongly urge you not to miss out on “Color Out of Space.” For me, this adaptation hits all the right notes. The practical effects are nothing short of spectacular, showcasing extreme body transformations that are both unsettling and awe-inspiring. And if, like me, you’re a fan of Nicolas Cage, then prepare to be blown away by his passionate and intense performance.

Read More

2024-07-24 21:01