Plane Crash Movie ‘Charlie Victor Romeo’ Breaks All the Rules

by

The New York Times movie critic A.O. Scott described Charlie Victor Romeo (2013) as one of the scariest movies he’s ever encountered, which might lead one to believe it’s a horror film. However, this isn’t your typical horror genre with ghosts or killers; instead, Charlie Victor Romeo focuses on the chilling reality of airplane accidents.

Unlike many films and shows that frequently portray plane crashes, “Charlie Victor Romeo” offers a distinctive perspective on its theme. Instead of fabricating a fictional aviation disaster, this production bases its stories on the actual cockpit voice recordings from six real catastrophic flights – often referred to as “black boxes”. The unique title “Charlie Victor Romeo” represents the abbreviation “CVR” in the NATO phonetic alphabet, a language used by pilots when communicating with ground control. This innovative piece combines documentary-style narratives, live stage performances, and cutting-edge 3D filmmaking techniques to provide audiences with an unnervingly realistic insight into how pilots handle mid-air emergencies, the critical choices they make to save lives, and the consequences of those decisions – whether they prove right or wrong.

Inspiration and Impact

Based on information from the project’s official site, it appears that the play titled “CVR” was initially penned by Robert Berger, Patrick Daniels, and Irving Gregory, who are members of the small, non-profit theater group Collective: Unconscious based in New York City. After carefully reviewing approximately 100 CVR (Cockpit Voice Recorder) transcripts, this trio chose six crashes that took place between 1985 and 1995. These incidents include American Airlines Flight 1572 (which had no fatalities), American Eagle Flight 4184, Aeroperú Flight 603, US Air Force Yukla 27, Japan Airlines Flight 123, and United Airlines Flight 232. The dialogue in the play is primarily drawn directly from the CVR recordings of these six flights, with only slight modifications for time adjustments.

The production of this play first hit the stage in the autumn of 1999, receiving rave reviews and accolades from both critics and the aviation industry, leading to a prolonged series of sold-out performances. In the ensuing years, it was staged multiple times across the United States and internationally. Remarkably, the US Air Force recorded the play in 2000 for pilot training purposes, and it has since been incorporated into engineering psychology classes at West Point. Even more captivating is its widespread appeal within the medical community, where the high-pressure, complex scenarios portrayed by the pilots are strikingly reminiscent of those encountered daily by ER doctors, nurses, and surgeons.

Planes Crash From Stage to Screen

The movie adaptation of “CVR” was first shown at the Sundance Film Festival in January 2013, and it was also screened at the AFI Fest in Los Angeles later that year. Directors Robert Berger, Patrick Daniels, and Karlyn Michelson chose to preserve the dim lighting and sparse stage setup from the play, which features only illuminated models of the cockpit control panels. However, they enhanced the film’s cinematic quality by employing 3D Stereoscopic cameras during production.

Amy Nicholson from LA Weekly observes that while a 3D movie about plane crashes might initially evoke thoughts of a Roland Emmerich spectacle, the modest and sparse cockpit set design prevents an overabundance of sensationalism. Instead of being overwhelmed by special effects, the audience is drawn to human behavior, as we are aware of the impending disaster – a fact that remains obscure to the pilots. Similarly, A.O. Scott comments on how the blend of minimalist set design, dim lighting, and 3D cinematography creates an ominous ambiance: “The 3D brings the characters on screen closer yet more ethereal at the same time. They float in a darkened void, striving against the impending and unavoidable darkness.

In this film adaptation, a captivating element carried over from the original play is the compact ensemble of actors portraying the pilots across all six flights, including the three directors themselves. This consistent cast gives the illusion that we’re witnessing the same pilots “in a sense, resurrecting,” which amplifies an unsettling, spectral detachment to an already tense experience. This unique casting approach sometimes means that the actors don’t perfectly mirror the ethnicity and/or gender of their real-life counterparts, as demonstrated by the Japanese crew in Flight 123. However, interviews with actual pilots who attended the play’s premiere reveal that despite any visual discrepancies, these actors deliver performances that resonate remarkably authentically with the true flight crews.

Unexpected Optimism

A striking similarity between Scott’s and Nicholson’s critiques lies in their description of the film depicting true plane crashes as surprisingly soothing and inspiring. Scott suggests this sensation arises from the film’s almost mundane atmosphere, which provides a comprehensive portrayal of what we already understand – that air travel is monotonous and generally secure, except for those rare, unfathomable instances when it becomes anything but. This observation highlights the crucial point about the impact of all six crashes, namely, the investigations following them brought about significant reforms in the aviation sector, enhancing safety for all passengers. However, CVR serves as a reminder that these advancements came at a heavy and heart-wrenching price, one that should never be overlooked.

Meanwhile, Nicholson cites Daniels as stating that CVR is hopeful because it demonstrates that “when things are tough, individuals attempt. They might be attempting the incorrect thing, but they’re still putting in tremendous effort.” In contrast, Berger contrasts the pragmatism of CVR with films like Final Destination (2000), where “the goal is to frighten…[while] fear isn’t our aim.” Instead, the film’s true purpose is to foster empathy for the brave pilots, as well as the active pilots who we entrust with our lives daily. In fact, according to Nicholson, Berger’s mother even started giving thank-you cards to the pilots on her flights after watching the play – precisely the type of response that the original playwrights had hoped for.

On the Charlie Victor Romeo website, you’ll find a list of places where you can rent or buy the movie (in digital format or Blu-ray) using this provided link.

Read More

2025-02-27 02:02