Ranking Every Scorsese and Pesci Film: Which One Reigns Supreme?

by

If you’re an avid film enthusiast, then you understand that when Martin Scorsese and Joe Pesci appear together in a movie title, it’s a signal for an exhilarating and indelible cinematic experience. Over four decades, this talented team has produced some of the most highly-regarded films, creating raw masterpieces that have secured them a spot among cinema legends.

Director Martin Scorsese, renowned for movies such as Taxi Driver, Goodfellas, and The Departed, is famous for his intense storytelling style that immerses viewers directly in the worlds depicted on screen. No actor has better captured the raw, dynamic spirit of Scorsese’s films than Joe Pesci, with his charisma, swagger, and eyes capable of transforming from playful to deadly within a blink of an eye, bringing some truly remarkable characters to life.

In the ’90s, my personal film journey was graced by the unparalleled collaboration between Martin Scorsese and Joe Pesci, two cinematic titans whose partnership yielded films that have become the cornerstones of their respective careers. These masterpieces include none other than the iconic “Goodfellas” and the gripping “Casino.” These movies elevated both their talents to unprecedented heights within their craft. Here’s a rundown of every film they jointly created:

1. Raging Bull (1980)
2. Goodfellas (1990)
3. Cape Fear (1991)
4. Casino (1995)
5. The Funny Game (1997)
6. Bringing Out the Dead (1999)
7. The Good Shepherd (2006)
8. The Irishman (2019)

4
‘Casino’ (1995)

The dazzling, scandalous, and tumultuous era of 1970s Las Vegas is portrayed in a tale revolving around Sam “Ace” Rothstein, a cunning small-time mobster and gaming specialist selected by the criminal syndicate to manage the Tangiers Casino’s daily affairs. Ace skillfully funnels the casino’s earnings into the pockets of his Mafia superiors, climbing the ranks in power, yet his path is fraught with shady partnerships, corporate maneuverings, temptations, and a tumultuous marriage to Ginger McKenna. Upon inviting his old buddy Nicky Santoro to serve as his enforcer within the casino, they set off a series of events marked by increasing violence and turmoil that could potentially bring the entire enterprise crashing down.

Scorcese’s World of Glamor and Excess

Stepping back into the gritty crime world I’ve grown fond of in “Goodfellas,” legendary director Martin Scorsese delivers another masterpiece that cements his position as the unparalleled storyteller in this genre. This movie is a crime epic brimming with Scorsese’s distinctive touches, including a captivating voice-over, dynamic cinematography, and an electrifying classic rock score, all combining to propel us into the abyss of greed and ambition. At the heart of this tale stands Joe Pesci, delivering perhaps his most maniacal performance ever as Nicky, a volatile enforcer whose reckless impulses and disregard for rules threaten the casino’s stability. Balancing him is the more calculated presence of Robert De Niro’s Ace. Their dynamic duo adds momentum and intensity to the movie, serving as a reflection of the chaotic energy within the casino itself.

The movie “Casino” bears some resemblance to “Goodfellas,” but it stands out as a unique production due to its grandiose portrayal of extravagance. This film garnered widespread recognition for its expansive narrative and sharp narrative skills. Notably, Sharon Stone’s portrayal of Ginger was highly commended, earning her an Academy Award Best Actress nomination. “Casino” amassed a global box office revenue of $116 million and maintains a strong 80% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

3
‘The Irishman’ (2019)

Approximately 25 years later, the legendary team of Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Martin Scorsese reunited for one final cinematic farewell. Titled The Irishman, this film unfolds like a melancholic ballad, detailing the lives of two long-time companions – a hitman and a mob boss – across six decades. The main character is Frank Sheeran, a labor union officer with a colorful history in organized crime, reflecting on his journey from an ordinary truck driver to a crucial member of the Bufalino crime family and his involvement in the disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa. Joe Pesci reappears on screen in a powerful and commanding performance as Russell Bufalino, a mob boss who pulls Frank further into the criminal underworld.

Subtle Brilliance in Character-Driven Storytelling

Approximately 3 hours and 30 minutes long, “The Irishman” embodies the essence of an epic tale. It’s a vast narrative that sees Martin Scorsese stepping away from the fast-paced intensity that characterized his previous successes, opting instead for a thoughtful and reflective style. Utilizing de-aging technology, he guides viewers through memory lane, recounting the story in a series of flashbacks to depict Frank’s gradual deterioration. This method was both daring and divisive, but the introspective approach enables the exploration of themes like loyalty, betrayal, and service within the Italian crime syndicate in a unique, character-driven manner. Robert Pesci delivers a subtle yet powerful performance as the clever, composed mob boss contemplating the transience of power, while Robert De Niro’s Frank and Al Pacino’s Hoffa leave an indelible impression.

The film “The Irishman” was highly praised by critics and became a strong contender during the awards season, earning ten nominations for Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director. Despite being released on Netflix and having only limited showings in theaters, it still resonated with a broad audience, stirring discussions about Martin Scorsese’s other mob-themed films. The movie’s box office revenue of $8 million may seem small compared to other big productions, but “The Irishman” stands as an impressive milestone in Scorsese’s career, boasting a remarkable 95% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

2
‘Raging Bull’ (1980)

Regardless of it being a biographical sports drama, “Raging Bull” stands out as one of the finest films ever created. Immersed in the gritty milieu of 1940s boxing, it chronicles the journey of Jake LaMotta, a middleweight fighter, as he relentlessly pursues his goal of becoming a world champion. This pursuit, however, often leads to destruction, not only in his professional life but also in his personal relationships. The narrative unfolds extensively, from Jake’s entry into the ring and his rapid ascension, to his marriage with Vickie and his tumultuous bond with his brother and manager, Joey, portrayed by Pesci.

A Black-and-White Ballet of Brutality

In “Raging Bull,” Scorsese skillfully constructs a raw and intense depiction of a man wrestling with inner turmoil, fueled by envy, animosity, and a compulsion for control. This is a tale of redemption and remorse, presented in such a compelling manner that it leaves an indelible mark not just on Scorsese’s illustrious filmography, but also on the broader landscape of American cinema. Robert De Niro delivers a tour de force performance as the talented yet self-hating Jake, while Pesci portrays Joey, a loyal friend who becomes exasperated by Jake’s repeated attempts to destroy his own life. Pesci effectively communicates a blend of affection and exasperation in his efforts to halt Jake’s downward spiral. Additionally, Cathy Moriarty’s Vickie adds an element of warmth and resilience amidst the brutal world of boxing.

Upon its debut, Raging Bull was met with widespread acclaim from critics, who admired its technical finesse and compelling storyline. It bagged two Academy Awards, one for Best Actor (De Niro) and received eight nominations, among which was Best Picture. Roger Ebert considered it the most potent and intricate film of its era. Despite a relatively modest commercial performance with a $23 million box office take, Raging Bull‘s cultural and critical impact has significantly increased over time. The movie enjoys an impressive approval rating of 94% on Rotten Tomatoes.

1
‘Goodfellas’ (1990)

In a natural and easy-to-read manner,

Martin Scorsese’s 1990 film, Goodfellas, is a captivating and heartrending crime saga. The story unfolds around Henry Hill, a young, mob-obsessed man who climbs the criminal ranks with his accomplices, Jimmy Conway and Tommy DeVito. Born to Irish and Sicilian parents, Henry quickly becomes a made man in the Lucchese crime family. However, as power corrupts him, violence and paranoia consume him. The film delves into Henry’s tumultuous marriage with Karen, but its heart lies in his volatile relationship with Tommy, brilliantly portrayed by Joe Pesci in an intense performance.

Unforgettable Masterpiece About Crime and Chaos

Goodfellas showcases Scorsese at the height of his directorial prowess, delving deep into the complex psyche of its gangster characters. With its swift tempo, it propels the story towards an explosive ending where Henry’s criminal empire disintegrates due to his self-destructive decisions. Its acclaimed status isn’t just based on the gripping plot but also the masterful cinematography, music, and acting by the entire cast. Pesci’s portrayal of Tommy DeVito is both unforeseeable and indelible; it combines humor and terror in equal measure. Featuring stellar performances from Ray Liotta, Robert De Niro, and Lorraine Bracco, this drug-infused journey serves as a poignant warning about how the chase for power and wealth can lead one down a dark and treacherous path.

Upon hitting the screens, I found myself deeply moved by “Goodfellas.” Critics hailed its release with widespread approval, commending its gritty intensity and innovative storytelling techniques. Rotten Tomatoes gave it a 96% score, reflecting a consensus that it’s perhaps the pinnacle of Martin Scorsese’s illustrious career. The film garnered six Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director, with Joe Pesci snatching the Best Supporting Actor award for his portrayal of Tommy DeVito. At the box office, “Goodfellas” earned $47 million globally, but its true allure lies in its legendary status as a masterpiece crafted by some of Hollywood’s finest talents. This timeless classic continues to captivate viewers time and again.

Read More

2025-03-28 01:02