Ridley Scott’s Napoleon: Why Movie Buffs Should Ignore the History Police and Just Watch It

by

Movies that frequently draw inspiration from historical events or figures, sometimes creating speculative biographies, have come up with innovative methods to portray history. These approaches range from historical fiction, where fictional characters are placed within real historical contexts, to meticulously researched accounts. The creative team behind these films must ensure they craft a narrative that resonates with today’s audiences. When history lacks certain details or experiences dramatic lulls, filmmakers utilize these moments as opportunities for creative interpretation.

A film like Ridley Scott’s “Napoleon” should primarily be viewed as a creative interpretation of historical events, shaped by the director’s perspective or the source material they utilized to craft the story. Due to the subjective nature of filmmaking, different versions can vary significantly from one another in their portrayal of historical events. As such, it is essential to remember that these films are not intended as factual accounts but rather artistic representations. Therefore, “Napoleon” remains an interesting and valuable watch for numerous reasons.

Ridley Scott’s Track Record Of Historically-Based Films And Shows Is Great

Since his debut film, “The Duelists“, Ridley Scott has consistently shown a deep affection and expertise in a particular genre – historical dramas. While he ventures into other genres to finance these large-scale costume productions, it’s clear that this is where his true passion lies. Apart from directing numerous historically accurate films, Scott has also produced several outstanding television series and miniseries within the genre. A notable example of his work in this area is the pair of miniseries he produced based on Ken Follett’s books, “The Pillars Of The Earth” and its sequel, “World Without End“. These shows not only stayed true to the spirit and detail of the original novels but also maintained the same level of historical authenticity that the books were renowned for.

Scott has a knack for creating sword-and-sandal-style epics but also explores recent history. He’s produced films set in the Napoleonic era, such as the series, and movies from the 60s, 70s, and 90s like American Gangster and Black Hawk Down. What makes Ridley Scott an exceptional director for period pieces is his talent for making viewers feel they’re part of the era, with meticulously crafted sets, locations, and costumes. He’s particular about music and sound editing to create the perfect atmosphere. In his medieval masterpiece, Kingdom of Heaven, the noisy hustle and bustle of Jerusalem contrasted with the tranquil French mountain town where Balian grew up, creating a realistic portrayal of the character’s culture shock. For less historically knowledgeable viewers, it’s both inspiring and encourages them to learn more about the era, while offering a romantic, epic entertainment experience that challenges them to delve into the facts themselves.

Ridley Scott’s Dramas Research The Look Of The Eras

  • The Napoleonic Wars were waged between 1803-1815, spanning 12 years.
  • Napoleon was nominated for three Academy Awards in Production Design, Costume Design, and Visual Effects.

As a self-made artist with roots in visual art, Ridley Scott examines both the art from specific eras and the subsequent art that was influenced by it during those periods. For instance, when creating the movie Napoleon, he utilized countless paintings in the Louvre depicting Napoleon’s victories as a reference for his grand set-pieces. Similarly, for Kingdom of Heaven, he drew inspiration from the Crusade tapestries housed at The Vatican to create authentic armor, weapons, costumes, and flags needed for the epic battle scenes. Additionally, Scott has delved into arms and armor exhibits at The Royal Armouries in the UK to ensure historical accuracy in his depictions of uniforms and armor throughout time.

Ridley Scott focuses on creating authentic visuals for historical accuracy in his films, followed by giving writers the freedom to combine extensive research with creative liberties to create an intense movie experience. Although a film like Napoleon might suggest a biographical approach, it actually presents a dramatic reinterpretation of Napoleon’s military exploits within the context of historical fiction, starting from his rise to fame and power. While Scott isn’t alone in this approach, many films have previously depicted specific aspects of Napoleon’s life with a more heroic and romantic spin. To create a distinct narrative, Scott chose not to cater to the public’s preference for a more romanticized portrayal of that era. Despite his relaxed attitude towards historical accuracy in his historical films, they still resonate positively with audiences.

Napoleon’s Director’s Cut Includes Much More

  • One of Ridley Scott’s most well-known director’s cuts is of his iconic film Blade Runner.
  • To date, Ridley Scott has released 11 director’s cuts of his films.

Beyond certain thematic deviations and creative licenses Ridley Scott employed in Napoleon, it’s no surprise that his approach has been a topic of discussion. Originally, his cut of Napoleon was approximately three-and-a-half hours long, significantly shorter than the initial suggested runtime when the film first premiered. However, the director’s cut provides additional historical context to some events that were briefly covered or condensed in the original release, which might satisfy viewers who felt certain nuances were missing. Often, distribution companies hesitate to release Scott’s films in their director’s cut due to his emphasis on detailed character and plot development alongside an immersive atmosphere. Therefore, it is best to experience Ridley Scott’s work when he can present the film as close as possible to his original vision.

As a cinephile, I must say that the extended director’s cut offers a more comprehensive glimpse into the life of the director, delving deeper into his military campaigns and the impact of his deteriorating health over time – aspects that were previously overlooked in the original release. This revised version also slows down the brisk pace at the film’s beginning, providing a richer portrayal of the revolution’s violence and chaos, and its effect on both Napoleon and France.

While it’s challenging to encapsulate Napoleon’s entire military career in a single film, even one as lengthy as this one, the additional depth provided by this extended cut undoubtedly improves the pacing and moderates the intense shifts in plot that were prevalent in the initial release.

Read More

2025-05-15 07:09