The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

As a die-hard wrestling fan who’s spent countless hours watching matches from the ’80s to the present day, I must say that AEW has truly revolutionized the world of professional wrestling. And if you ask me who have been the most influential figures in this new era, my dear friend, let me tell you, they are none other than these legends who dared to break away from the WWE and join forces with Tony Khan to create something extraordinary.

I’m really into All Elite Wrestling (AEW). To be honest, it rekindled my interest in professional wrestling altogether.

It’s clear that All Elite Wrestling (AEW) wouldn’t be as prominent as it is now without the consistent influx of WWE wrestlers they’ve acquired over time.

AEW owes a significant part of its success to some of WWE’s former top-tier stars like Malakai Black, Brodie Lee (RIP), and Bobby Lashley. While talents such as MJF, Darby Allin, and “Hangman” Adam Page have been the mainstays in AEW, it’s crucial to acknowledge that without these 10 former WWE wrestlers, AEW might not be the topic of conversation we see today in the world of professional wrestling.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

10. Sting (Became All Elite in 2020)

Against all odds, an incredible comeback occurred – one many thought would never transpire. After suffering a severe neck injury in 2016 that led him to retire from wrestling, Sting astonishingly made a return to the ring in 2020 and concluded his career in 2024.

What a legend.

As a devoted fan, I must say that when Sting made his comeback to wrestling, teaming up with Darby Allin was an ideal match. However, as time went by, the legend himself started to shake things up in the ring, taking some jaw-dropping hits even at 60 years old. Quite impressive!

What gives Sting significant weight in AEW, however, is his rich history. This individual has had extended, impactful careers in WCW, TNA, as well as WWE, and opted to conclude his professional journey in AEW. As I mentioned earlier, he truly embodies the essence of a legend.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

9. Mercedes Mone (Became All Elite in 2024)

As Sasha Banks and Naomi exited RAW, ripples echoed across the wrestling world. Some may question their motives for departing, but there’s no disputing that she parted ways with a powerful “Boss”-like flair, much like one of her renowned aliases.

Leaving the biggest wrestling promotion in the world is no small decision, but the former Sasha Banks decided that she wasn’t satisfied with the direction of her character in WWE, so she left.

She disappeared for a while, but kept being sighted at AEW events, only to eventually become All Elite in 2024, where she made a huge splash in the Women’s Division.

Previously, I penned thoughts on potential reasons for switching from AEW to WWE. One factor was the perceived mistreatment of the Women’s Division. Yet, since Moné’s arrival, she has been provided captivating storylines that have significantly boosted the Women’s Division, reaching new peaks. Bravo!

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

8. Christian Cage (Became All Elite in 2021)

Previously, I expressed my belief that Kurt Angle is the finest wrestler to have donned a pair of boots, and I still firmly hold onto that opinion. Yet, should you ask about the wrestler whose career I find most remarkable, it’s Edge (Christian Cage).

As I pen down my thoughts, I can confidently affirm that this veteran in the squared circle has not lost his touch. This conviction stems from the impressive 26 title victories he’s amassed across various wrestling promotions, a testament to his enduring prowess.

To put it simply, Christian Cage’s strongest trait might be his ability to perform impressive heel work, as there’s no one quite like him at stirring up a crowd. Nicknamed “the Patriarch” in AEW, Cage is a magnet for negative reactions, and somehow manages to make himself even more detested than MJF ever was.

His influence is in developing engaging storylines with almost anyone; hearing his signature melody guarantees an impressive viewing experience.)

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

7. Swerve Strickland (Became All Elite in 2022)

Who owns that house? Frankly, it seems to me that WWE missed an opportunity with Swerve Strickland. He shone brilliantly as Isaiah “Swerve” Scott in NXT, but his tenure on SmackDown didn’t seem to last very long.

On the contrary, too bad for them. Since joining All Elite, Strickland has been a highly sought-after wrestler. He’s been involved in thrilling rivalries, such as his recent one with “Hangman” Adam Page, and was once part of the sensational tag-team Swerve in Our Glory with Keith Lee, another former WWE star.

Swerve excels at dishing out punishment, yet he’s equally skilled at selling, ensuring that each match feels dynamic and full of back-and-forth action.

Swerve’s influence lies primarily in his portrayal of characters. Regardless of the match he participates in, it’s difficult to predict the winner, which I believe is a clear reflection of Strickland’s versatility. This man could potentially be a World Champion one moment, and the next, help another contender shine. He truly embodies the spirit of a genuine performer.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

6. Toni Storm (Became All Elite in 2022)

Did you know when I mentioned that Mercedes Mone significantly raised the bar for the Women’s Division in AEW? Since then, Toni Storm seems to have been shouldering that responsibility with great effort after her arrival.

In every match she’s had while working for this promotion, Toni Storm has consistently delivered top-notch performances. Furthermore, her “Timeless” Toni Storm persona not only revamped her character but also injected a fresh and enjoyable vibe into the Women’s Division.

It was at this point that I truly understood how valuable Storm was to our business, as she appeared to be someone straight out of a classic black-and-white film.

Despite no longer using a character gimmick, Storm’s influence remains crucial to the Women’s Division’s thriving state. She lends credibility to it, not only through her exceptional skills but also her captivating performances, aspects that should never be overlooked.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

5. CM Punk (Became All Elite in 2021)

Oh, CM Punk, what might have been such a great story. Unfortunately, one of AEW’s less savory decisions was to broadcast the video of his altercation behind the scenes, an action that inadvertently tarnished their own reputation even more.

Now, he’s returned to the WWE, which makes me extremely joyful. To clarify, his tenure in AEW was unforgettable as well.

Initially, it’s my belief that AEW hasn’t experienced a greater audience reaction upon his debut compared to this moment.

Above all, he was the star host of the Saturday evening program, Collision. Unfortunately, it didn’t succeed, but he is undeniably the most recognized figure the company has ever known.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

4. Bryan Danielson (Became All Elite in 2021)

It’s likely that Bryan Danielson might have continued his retirement when he departed from WWE due to his numerous injuries; however, he experienced one of his most intriguing periods in AEW.

Danielson is frequently found facing off against various opponents, earning a reputation as the highly-skilled, technical wrestler within AEW.

As a devoted admirer, I’d like to highlight that his time with the Black Pool Combat Club, now known as the Death Riders, was simply outstanding within the company. His unique dynamic with Chris Jericho, who masterfully portrayed the “Sports Entertainer” persona (a clever nod to the McMahon era-WWE), was a standout element that truly captivated me.

It’s quite clear that Danielson’s presence significantly enhances the quality of matches in our promotion to unprecedented levels. However, considering the toll his career has taken on his body, it would be wise for him to stick with retirement this time.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

3. Jon Moxley (Became All Elite in 2019)

Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson both deliver top-notch performances and maintain a high level of consistency in their matches. However, it’s worth noting that Jon Moxley has been with AEW for a longer period compared to Bryan Danielson.

As a passionate moviegoer, I’d say that among ex-WWE wrestlers, Mox has undoubtedly had the most captivating journey. He shines brighter in AEW than he ever did in the WWE, making him the standout star of the ring.

While AEW is not ECW when it comes to violence, they’re definitely a sharp contrast to WWE.

In essence, Mox stands as a symbol of all that violence, regardless of whether it’s for good or ill, and his own countenance frequently bears the marks of that gory redness.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

2. Chris Jericho (Became All Elite in 2019)

Sting is often referred to as “The Icon,” but Chris Jericho equally deserves that title. He was present since the initial year of the company, making him the first recognizable wrestler in AEW, symbolizing that it truly was an “Elite” promotion from the start.

Before joining AEW, he had already built such a storied career that it felt like a clear indication of the uniqueness and potential greatness of this promotion when Jericho decided to lend his reputation and influence to it.

Ever since then, he’s been quite the busybody, always involved in various activities, and it’s rare not to find him engaged in some venture or another.

His influence consistently keeps All Elite Wrestling (AEW) vibrant. Through his diverse personas, he frequently steers the entire organization, and it’s safe to say that no other wrestler has had a greater impact on AEW, with perhaps one exception.

The 10 Most Impactful Former WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been In AEW, Ranked

1. Cody Rhodes (Became All Elite in 2019)

It’s quite possible that All Elite Wrestling (AEW) wouldn’t have been established without Cody Rhodes. From its inception, he played a crucial role in helping AEW take flight, essentially making him indispensable for the creation and existence of the brand.

Despite some unforgettable battles, the audience eventually grew disenchanted with him due to his prolonged role as a fan favorite. His exit from the organization significantly altered its trajectory for good.

Furthermore, his tenure as Mr. AEW was temporary… until it ended. Now, he’s the Mr. WWE, which I’m pleased to see.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-12-21 17:07