The First Sequel To Win The Best Picture Oscar Is A Beloved Crime Epic

by

1974 saw Paramount Pictures unveil “The Godfather Part II,” a highly-regarded sequel that boasted the original film’s creative team and an impressive ensemble headed by Al Pacino, Robert De Niro, and Diane Keaton. This masterpiece swiftly climbed to equal its predecessor in prestige among 1970s films, and in 1975, it made history as the first sequel to secure the Academy Award for Best Picture.

This event was quite significant, not just due to its continuation of the triumphant start with “The Godfather,” but also because sequels were less frequent in the 1970s compared to now. Even though they were still a crucial aspect of movie releases, sequels were typically confined to genre films intended to appeal to a broad, often younger demographic. These sequels were primarily associated with monster movies that originated from films like “Bride of Frankenstein” in the 1930s, and adventure series such as the James Bond franchise.

In the realm of high-end cinema, sequels were less common, yet Paramount recognized a chance to prolong “The Godfather’s” narrative, and director Francis Ford Coppola identified an opportunity to wield greater creative authority to craft a distinctive sequel that would uphold the high standard established by “The Godfather.” The outcome wasn’t merely a successful sequel or an Academy Award winner, but one of the greatest films ever made. Here, we delve into how “The Godfather Part II” managed such an achievement.

Why The Godfather Part II was so successful

An essential point to bear in mind about the “The Godfather” series is that Francis Ford Coppola initially had no inclination towards directing a sequel. Following its release in 1972, the movie garnered phenomenal praise, broke box office records, and won three Academy Awards, including Best Picture; however, for Coppola, it was an uphill struggle to get the film made as he initially envisioned. Despite his reluctance, Paramount Pictures presented him with an offer that he couldn’t turn down – more financial compensation and greater creative freedom, in terms reminiscent of the world depicted in “The Godfather.

With the powerful reputation of a successful film director and an ensemble cast featuring both fresh and familiar characters, Coppola and Mario Puzo embarked on creating a cinematic masterpiece that would serve as both a sequel and a prequel to “The Godfather.” The narrative continued Michael Corleone’s reign following his father Vito’s demise, but “The Godfather Part II” also delved into the past, transporting us back to 1910s New York City. Here, we find a jobless Vito Corleone (portrayed by Robert De Niro), who, due to local crime bosses, turns to a life of crime and rises rapidly within his community through power and influence.

Personally, I found the film’s narrative to be a captivating juxtaposition. While Vito climbed higher, Michael seemed to falter, with Vito embodying integrity and strength, contrasted by Michael’s increasing compromises and weakness. One family thrived, while another disintegrated. It was an engaging spectacle that left audiences craving more.

The legacy of The Godfather Part II

The sequel to “The Godfather,” titled “The Godfather Part II,” was well-received by both critics and viewers. It expanded upon the original storyline, offering a fresh, unique plot written by Francis Ford Coppola and Mario Puzo. This new narrative delved not only into the rise and decline of organized crime but also presented a distinct perspective on American history.

Back in 1975, I was utterly blown away when “The Godfather Part II” swept the Oscars, surpassing its predecessor with an impressive six wins! It took home another best picture, best adapted screenplay, and Coppola snatched the best director award. To this very day, it’s one of only two sequels (with “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King” being the other) to claim the prestigious best picture title. What truly sets it apart is that it remains the sole sequel to win the award while its predecessor had already done so too!

Although it didn’t spawn numerous best picture-winning follow-ups, “The Godfather Part II” continues to be remembered as an exceptional sequel that matches or surpasses its original counterpart in the collective consciousness. Beyond this, it broadened the possibilities for sequels in Hollywood, with Coppola and Puzo crafting a narrative that not only continued the earlier storyline but also enriched the initial film’s context. Essentially, these films can be viewed as a unified narrative, and a miniseries adaptation, “The Godfather Saga,” combining both movies was released in 1977. It remains an exemplary sequel, offering valuable lessons for modern filmmakers.

Read More

2025-05-15 17:30