The Sopranos’ Hidden References to Classic Mob Movies

by

The Sopranos is often hailed as one of the greatest mob tales ever spun, and deservedly so. It’s an expansive narrative that employs the secluded milieu of the Italian mafia to scrutinize American life at the dawn of the 21st Century. For over a century, the mafia has held a captivating allure for many Americans, and stories about gangsters have been a common theme in movies and TV shows since their inception. Remarkably, The Sopranos acknowledges its role within this legacy and even engages in dialogue with other crime sagas of the genre.

In “The Sopranos,” humor from Silvio (Steven Van Zandt) mimicking Michael Corleone and mobsters discussing their deeds like those portrayed in “Goodfellas” is frequent. These references root the narrative in a familiar setting, yet they also showcase how the characters are perceived by outsiders and how they perceive themselves.

Cinematic Allusions in ‘The Sopranos‘

It’s evident from the very beginning that The Sopranos has a deep affection for cinema. Whenever a character is watching or discussing an old film, it serves as a platform to explore connections with the current episode or the show as a whole. For instance, Tony Soprano (played by James Gandolfini) often ponders about the decline of traditional American masculinity in his therapy sessions, questioning where the “taciturn heroes” like Gary Cooper have gone. This theme resurfaces throughout the series, with Tony expressing a longing for a time that may not have truly existed. For characters such as Tony and his crew, movie personas provide an aspiration to emulate and a means of grieving for a past that might only be fictional. Mafia-style characters in films like Goodfellas and Scarface also shape the way they perceive their own reality.

For those not involved with organized crime, portrayals of gangsters in media can create a misconception about the reality of living that lifestyle. People outside the circle often form assumptions about characters like Tony and his associates based on these stories, maintaining a safe distance. In the first-season episode “A Hit is a Hit,” Tony joins his neighbor Dr. Bruce Cusamano (Robert LuPone) and his wealthy friends for golf, where they inquire about the accuracy of The Godfather and if Tony knew John Gotti. Tony quickly recognizes that these men are attempting to distance him, treating him more as an oddity than a person. Despite having wealth, Tony will never truly be accepted among them.

As a film enthusiast, I find myself reflecting on a familiar theme when Tony, in his quest for a new therapist following his brief separation from Dr. Melfi (Lorraine Bracco), encounters one who denies treatment based on moral and ethical principles, partly referencing the 1999 comedy “Analyze This” as precedent. For those not immersed in the mafia world, our knowledge of that lifestyle primarily stems from Hollywood narratives, making it inevitable for such portrayals to be unrealistic.

Gangster Movies’ Effect on Italian-Americans

As a passionate film enthusiast, I often find myself reflecting on the portrayal of Italian-Americans in various media, particularly in shows like “The Sopranos.” Characters within this series, whether they’re deep within the mob or living ordinary lives, frequently express their frustration over the stereotypes associated with Italians.

Tony and his Uncle Junior, for instance, often lament that the significant contributions of Italians to Western culture – from artistic masterpieces to delectable cuisine – are overlooked due to mafia stories. They argue that these cultural advancements were, in part, stifled by limited opportunities for progression outside of organized crime.

Meanwhile, Dr. Melfi, an Italian-American psychotherapist, and her husband Richard grapple with differing perspectives on her treatment of Tony. Dr. Melfi believes that she can help him change for the better, while Richard contends that individuals like Tony perpetuate the damaging stereotype that all Italian-Americans are involved in organized crime.

It’s worth noting that The Sopranos faced accusations similar to itself during its broadcast. Various Italian-American advocacy organizations claimed that the show perpetuated damaging stereotypes, which ironically reinforced the negative portrayal of their culture that the series was critiquing. Whether these allegations hold water is still a topic for discussion, but it adds an additional metafictional dimension to the show’s examination of the cultural influence of such narratives.

David Chase, the show’s creator along with his writing team, often use the structure of the series as a means to challenge viewers about their tolerance for violence. Instead of relying heavily on mafia-style killings, they opted for a more thoughtful and restrained approach. In the 2024 documentary titled “Wise Guy: David Chase and The Sopranos,” Chase discusses this disparity between the show’s viewers and its content, noting that many expected “less talking, more action” – essentially craving a more traditional mafia narrative.

In creating “The Sopranos,” Chase and his team intentionally aimed to construct a storyline that would challenge the stereotypes prevalent in typical gangster narratives, often finding itself at odds with its own audience. This internal conflict is one of the reasons why the show continues to captivate viewers even 25 years after its debut, offering an intriguing and thought-provoking series.

Read More

2025-04-13 23:32