‘The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat’ Review: Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, Uzo Aduba and Sanaa Lathan Buoy Routine Female-Friendship Drama

‘The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat’ Review: Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, Uzo Aduba and Sanaa Lathan Buoy Routine Female-Friendship Drama

As a gamer with over three decades of experience under my belt, I’ve seen countless tales of camaraderie and friendship unfold across various platforms – from the pixelated worlds of early RPGs to the immersive narratives of modern video games. But none have resonated quite as deeply as the story of the Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat.


In 1968, three young individuals with a vibrant energy strolled into a diner. Upon noticing them, Earl, the kind proprietor of this Midwestern establishment, couldn’t resist commenting. Their self-assured charm reminded him of Diana, Mary, and Florence. Thus, he nicknamed them the Supremes, a name that soon became synonymous with them.

Over the next three decades, Odette (Kyanna “KeeKee” Simone), Clarice (Abigail Achiri) and Barbara Jean (Tati Gabrielle) will regularly gather at Earl’s, settle into their favorite booth, confide in one another, provide solace, and celebrate life with the most indulgent milkshakes.

As a gamer, I’d put it this way:

The story of these three women, known as the Supremes, starts with their births in 1950, but we encounter them in 1999. Odette (played by Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor) is seated at the foot of a tree in hospital garb, setting the narrative through her voiceover. She introduces us to her friendship with Clarice (Uzo Aduba) and Barbara Jean (Sanaa Lathan), which blossomed during their teenage years. As African-American girls growing up in mid-century, they were born into a society that frequently undervalued them. Yet, they remained resolute in their ambition to alter their destinies. Odette aspired to be a nurse; Clarice was an exceptional pianist; and though Barbara Jean claimed she had no interests, her pursuit of self-love was equally significant.

Mabry’s reworking of Moore’s book beautifully and powerfully depicts profound friendships between older African American women. The central storyline unfolds near the turn of the millennium, as the trio gather for Earl’s funeral. Earl’s passing serves as a catalyst for introspection among the group. They start questioning the quality of their lives: Are they individuals their younger selves would look up to with pride?

To address this query, Mabry alternates between describing events from the past and the present. In the play “The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat“, there are frequent shifts from the year 1999 to significant earlier periods. A brief stop in the 1950s gives us insight into their beginnings, and we get a glimpse of each girl’s birth through a series of flashbacks. The narrative then moves forward to 1968 where we discover not only their initial meeting but also how young Odette (Simone) and Clarice (Achiri) saved Barbara Jean (Gabrielle) from her abusive stepfather.

In 1970, two years after the initial events, we follow the stories of several girls as they experience love, heartbreak, and growing up. The determined Odette pursues shy James, who is portrayed as a teenager by Dijon Means and as an adult by Mekhi Phifer. Meanwhile, Clarice captures the attention of charismatic football player Richmond, played by Xavier Mills in his teenage years and Russell Hornsbry as an adult. Barbara Jean grapples with her feelings for Ray, a white busboy at Earl’s, portrayed as a teenager by Ryan Paynter and as an adult by Julian McMahon. Additionally, she is also drawn to the safer affections of Lester, played by Cleveland Berto in his youth and Vondie Curtis Hall as an adult.

In much the same way as movies like “Waiting to Exhale” or the “The Best Man” series, The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat exists within a world that is heavy with emotional intensity. The storyline often leans on familiar tropes to guide its characters from one scene to another. Predictably, after a period of sadness, there comes a moment of emotional resolution. There’s seldom a significant pause between a somber moment and a triumphant one. Cinematography by Sean McElwee (DP) and a dramatic score by Kathryn Bostic (“Toni Morrison: The Pieces I Am”) guide us through this emotional rollercoaster. The film’s heartfelt tone is crafted through close-ups of tearful faces and wide shots of sunlight sparkling on water, creating a sense of serene beauty.

The actresses who portray both the young and old Supremes give the movie “The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat” a sense of reality, making its emotional depth and climax seem genuine rather than flimsy. Their performances help to keep the film grounded.

The thrill of seeing Ellis-Taylor work never gets old. In The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat, she assumes the role of a woman whose identity as the maternal figure in the group gets shaken when she is diagnosed with cancer. Now, Odette — always the fighter, never afraid to speak her mind — must ask for help. Aduba’s Clarice is a piano prodigy who gave up a life of touring to start a family with Richmond. In her, we see a woman who must learn to defend herself and her dreams. Lathan’s Barbara Jean is the friend whose life has been the most defined by tragedy. In the moments when all three women are onscreen together, their dynamic is electric.

Simone, Achiri, and Gabrielle radiate a certain spirit whenever Mabry transports us to the past. Their characters, whether they’re standing up for each other against teenage tormentors, providing harsh truths, or supporting one another through tough life choices, offer compelling performances that emphasize the excitement of early friendships and strengthen our faith in their enduring bonds as well. They hold our attention, causing us to understand that “The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat” is fundamentally a story about how friendships transform into familial ties.

Read More

2024-08-08 05:55