These 10 Remakes Were So Good They Got Best Picture Nods!

by

As a cinephile, I’ve often found myself embroiled in the ongoing discussion about movie remakes – a topic that can be as elusive as it is contentious. More times than not, the endeavor to recapture the enchantment of a cherished classic falls flat, leaving viewers yearning for the allure and genius of the original. However, there are exceptions to this rule; instances where remakes miraculously surpass the expectations set by their predecessors, not just replicating the original’s essence but also elevating the material to unprecedented heights. These are cinematic marvels, the exceptional cases where the creative team and cast manage to capture lightning in a bottle, resulting in critically acclaimed masterpieces.

This list features ten film remakes that have been highly acclaimed by both critics and audiences, even earning a prestigious nomination for Best Picture at the Oscars. Ranging from modern interpretations of timeless stories like the refreshed take on A Star Is Born, to daring reinterpretations of Western classics such as True Grit, these movies demonstrate that remakes are not a dying art. In fact, some of these films surpassed their nominations and were awarded the Best Picture Oscar.

10
‘Ben-Hur’ (1959)

In the grand annals of cinema, only a handful of narratives have been reimagined with such grandeur as the saga of Judah Ben-Hur. The film, simply titled Ben-Hur, revolves around the Jewish prince, whose life takes an unexpected turn when his childhood companion, Messala, falsely accuses him of treason. From being a slave to seeking retribution, the story reaches its climax in the legendary chariot race between Judah and Messala.

The Greatest Remake in History

The 1959 film “Ben-Hur” is a modern adaptation of the 1925 silent movie, which in turn was inspired by Lew Wallace’s novel from 1880. This movie, masterfully directed by William Wyler, offers stunning visual spectacles and pulse-pounding action scenes that are still unmatched to this day. The film’s grand finale, its profound religious themes, and the technical prowess displayed throughout are all noteworthy. Remarkably, “Ben-Hur” earned an unprecedented 11 Academy Awards, among which was the award for Best Picture.

9
‘Heaven Can Wait’ (1978)

Harry Segall’s play of the same name was first adapted into a movie called Here Comes Mr. Jordan, following which directors Warren Beatty and Buck Henry decided to put the same story on screen with a twist. Heaven Can Wait is a fantasy comedy about Joe Pendleton, a Los Angeles Rams quarterback, who is plucked from the prime of his life and taken to Heaven. But because it was a mistake, Joe is sent back to Earth in the body of a recently murdered millionaire, leaving him to try and reclaim his life and pursue his dreams.

Captures the Spirit of the Original

Among Beatty’s finest and heartwarming films ever, “Heaven Can Wait” stands out for its skillful blend of fantasy storytelling with numerous amusing instances. In this movie, Beatty delivers a career-best performance as Joe, supported by a brilliant ensemble including Julie Christie and James Mason. The film’s surprising reincarnation plot unfolds in a series of cleverly humorous scenes that are equally witty and endearing. The remake garnered nine nominations for the Academy Awards.

8
‘Moulin Rouge!’ (2001)

In the colorful realm of “Moulin Rouge!“, a captivating musical, the border between real life and imagination fades. It whisks audiences away to Paris at the dawn of the 20th century. The narrative revolves around Christian, a budding English author, who yearns to be part of the Bohemian lifestyle in Montmartre. He finds himself smitten with Satine, the main attraction of the Moulin Rouge cabaret, a courtesan by profession. However, their affection is not devoid of sorrow.

A Dazzling Musical Masterpiece

Under the guidance of visionary filmmaker Baz Luhrmann, Moulin Rouge! marks the concluding chapter in his Red Curtain Trilogy, following Strictly Ballroom and Romeo + Juliet. Following the massive success of the latter, Luhrmann aimed to deliver another hit by reinventing the 1952 film originally directed by John Huston. This decision proved inspired, as Moulin Rouge! offers a visual spectacle that captivates the senses. The movie’s tale of two passionate lovers is only one of its many highlights; it also excels due to its daring set design, modern music, and standout performances from Ewan McGregor and Nicole Kidman. Moulin Rouge! was nominated for eight Academy Awards and ultimately won two.

7
‘The Departed’ (2006)

The Crossed Paths

This gripping tale of crime unfolds in the city of Boston. It revolves around two individuals on opposing sides of the law: Billy Costiga, an undercover officer embedded within the Irish mafia, and Colin Sullivan, a police insider secretly working for criminal kingpin Frank Costello. As their lives intersect, they each strive to outmaneuver one another while keeping their true natures hidden. The ensuing confrontation results in a nerve-wracking and dramatic conclusion.

Tension and Transformation

In Martin Scorsese’s skilled direction, the 2006 film “The Departed” receives a remarkable portrayal. This film is actually a remake of the 2002 Hong Kong thriller, “Infernal Affairs,” which boasts a similar narrative and themes, both being equally impressive. “The Departed” stands out as a cinematic masterpiece due to its exploration of corruption, the repercussions of living a life shrouded in deceit, all presented in a stylish and somber manner. The performances by Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, and Jack Nicholson are nothing short of extraordinary, creating an intense atmosphere of constant suspense and intricate moral dilemmas. Not only was “The Departed” nominated for an Oscar, but it also marked Scorsese’s first win for Best Picture.

6
‘True Grit’ (2010)

In a classic Western tale titled “True Grit“, we follow the adventurous quest of 14-year-old Mattie Ross who is on a mission to avenge her father’s death. She’s a resilient and shrewd young girl, demonstrating her strength by recruiting the help of a seasoned U.S. Marshal named Rooster Cogburn and a Texas Ranger called LaBoeuf. Together, they chase after the murderer, Tom Chaney, through the treacherous landscapes of the American frontier. Along their journey, not only do they confront physical danger but also test the limits of their determination and trust.

Surpasses the Original

2010’s “True Grit,” directed by the Coen brothers, Joel and Ethan, is a standout modern classic for numerous reasons. It’s an impressive remake of the 1969 film starring John Wayne, while also paying tribute to its roots. However, it adds its own unique, dramatic touch to the story. The outstanding direction, intricate plot development, and stellar performances by actors like Josh Brolin, Jeff Bridges, and Hailee Steinfeld, resulted in ten Academy Award nominations that were truly merited.

5
‘A Star Is Born’ (2018)

Under Bradley Cooper’s direction and featuring himself along with Lady Gaga, this emotionally stirring musical journey navigates the realm of music and stardom seamlessly. The story unfolds as a chance meeting between Jackson Maine, an established musician, and Ally, an emerging vocalist. As Jackson’s career starts to wane, he inspires Ally to chase her aspirations, leading to her talent blossoming and causing a mix of affection and conflict between them.

Visually Stunning and Emotionally Raw

2018’s “A Star Is Born” marks the fourth retelling of the tragic love story, tracing back to 1937, with adaptations also happening in 1954 and 1976. Bradley Cooper’s directorial debut stands out as one of the most powerful renditions because it authentically portrays the intense emotions tied to the challenges faced while pursuing stardom in the entertainment world. Additionally, this version provided Lady Gaga with some of her most mesmerizing and impactful performances ever. In her role as Ally, she truly shines. Her undeniable chemistry with Jackson and their exceptional vocal prowess earned the film a notable nine Academy Awards nominations, including Best Picture.

4
‘Little Women’ (2019)

In a charming retelling of Louisa May Alcott’s 1868 novel titled “Little Women,” we trace the lives of four spirited March sisters: Jo, Meg, Beth, and Amy. Set against the backdrop of post-Civil War America, the film portrays their struggles as they mature into young women, each with unique personalities, aspirations, and longings. The movie beautifully illustrates their transformation from youth to maturity, as they carve out their individual destinies in life.

Contemporary Spin on a Timeless Classic

Under Greta Gerwig’s direction, the seventh cinematic interpretation of a cherished tale is acclaimed for its innovative and emotional touch, as well as its ability to breathe new life into a timeless story with contemporary nuances. The film’s unique narrative structure is one of its defining features. This groundbreaking movie garnered six Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, thanks to its intricate plot, stunning visuals, and profound character development. Saoirse Ronan, Emma Watson (in her last role to date), Florence Pugh, Laura Dern, Timothée Chalamet, and Meryl Streep lend their exceptional talents to the film, enhancing its overall appeal.

3
‘West Side Story’ (2021)

Revisiting the lively streets of 1950s New York City, West Side Story narrates the forbidden romance between Tony and Maria, who belong to opposing street gangs – the Jets and the Sharks respectively. Their love ignites amidst the strife between their groups, eventually escalating into a fateful confrontation that immerses them in a violent territorial dispute. The story delves into themes of love, discrimination, and brutality.

A Dazzling and Immersive Experience

Drawing inspiration from William Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet,” the 2021 movie directed by Steven Spielberg serves as an updated version of the 1961 musical, itself adapted from the Broadway musical penned by Leonard Bernstein and Stephen Sondheim. This new film stands out with its visually stunning scenes, enchanting musical compositions, and rhythmic dance sequences that will make you tap your toes. In contrast to the 1961 film, it adheres more closely to the original Broadway play’s storyline and boasts a charming ensemble headed by Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler. The revamped “West Side Story” has garnered seven Academy Award nominations.

2
‘Nightmare Alley’ (2021)

The movie “Nightmare Alley” is a gripping psychological thriller that unfolds in the world of 1940s carnivals. It centers around Stanton Carlisle, a cunning carnival worker with an uncanny knack for influencing others, who rises through the ranks and teams up with Dr. Lilith Ritter, a morally bankrupt psychiatrist, to swindle the upper class. However, their ambition and deceit take them down a far more sinister path than they ever anticipated.

A Gripping Exploration of Greed

2021’s “Nightmare Alley” is a reimagining of the 1947 film noir masterpiece bearing the same title, derived from William Lindsay Gresham’s novel. The film captivates audiences with its intricate and chilling narrative, delving into the dark side of ambition. Guillermo del Toro directs, meticulously highlighting the tense atmosphere and character growth, thereby instilling a tangible feeling of discomfort in each scene. It amassed four Academy Award nominations, alongside acclaim for its craftsmanship and execution.

1
‘CODA’ (2021)

Wrapping things up with a touching reinterpretation that ultimately won the Best Picture accolade, we present Sian Heder’s movie CODA. The film centers around Ruby Rossi, the sole hearing member of her deceased family, who is caught between their dependence on her and her aspirations to be a singer. As she matures, she finds it increasingly challenging to juggle her responsibilities for her family’s fishing business while discovering her own voice and direction in life.

Profound Story with Authentic Representation

Without a doubt, CODA shines like a gem on the big screen, being a remake of the 2014 French film La Famille Bélier. It masterfully combines humor and drama, offering a heartfelt depiction of the hearing-impaired community that resonates with empathy and truth. Critics have applauded it for its sincere portrayal of familial ties and its commitment to inclusivity. The exceptional acting skills of Emilia Jones, as Ruby, take center stage in this film, while Troy Kotsur, Marlee Matlin, and Daniel Durant deliver equally captivating performances as part of the supporting cast.

Read More

2025-02-19 05:02