‘Thunderbolts*’: All the Parts That Don’t Work

The movie titled “Thunderbolts” has been highly appreciated by both viewers and critics, bringing in good revenue at the box office and receiving some of the most favorable reviews within the Marvel Cinematic Universe for quite a while. However, was it flawless?

In our recent issue of Thunderbolts*, we gathered a team of Marvel specialists to jointly evaluate the movie. Overall, they enjoyed it and will explain their reasons. (Kudos to Florence Pugh.) However, we each have some minor reservations as well. Topics ranging from Bucky’s storyline to the absence of Ghost’s narrative will be discussed. Additionally, they will analyze the film’s ending and its implications for the future of the MCU in The Fantastic Four: First Steps and Avengers: Doomsday.

Gather around with Ryan Arey, Harriet Lengel-Enright, Matt Singer from ScreenCrush, and Rachel Leishman of The Mary Sue as they share their comprehensive review of the film Thunderbolts below:

*Note: *Thunderbolts is a fictional movie title.

Join Ryan Arey, Harriet Lengel-Enright, Matt Singer, and Rachel Leishman as they provide their complete review of the movie Thunderbolts below:

*Note: *Thunderbolts is a fictional movie title.

If you enjoyed the video we made about Thunderbolts, discussing why it was effective and potential improvements, don’t forget to explore more of our videos below! You might be interested in one that delves into the ending of Thunderbolts and the future of the MCU, another summarizing all the Marvel Cinematic Universe movies and shows leading up to Thunderbolts, and a third analyzing all the Easter eggs found in the first full Fantastic Four: First Steps trailer. There are plenty more videos available on ScreenCrush’s YouTube channel, so make sure to subscribe for future episodes. Right now, Thunderbolts is playing in theaters!

Sign up for Disney+ here.

Every Marvel Cinematic Universe Movie, Ranked From Worst to Best

36. Eternals

Initially, I wouldn’t have anticipated a Marvel film directed by an Academy Award-winner, adapting some of Jack Kirby’s groundbreaking comics, would result in the least significant title for the company. Regrettably, the movie Eternals, unfortunately, didn’t live up to its potential. It generally follows Kirby’s fundamental concepts with minor but quite disappointing alterations, such as transforming the antagonistic Deviants into uninteresting monsters without clear objectives or motivations. The ensemble cast boasts commendable supporting roles by Kumail Nanjiani and Brian Tyree Henry, however, the main characters – Gemma Chan as Sersi and Richard Madden as Ikaris – struggle to convincingly portray their long-standing romantic relationship. (Their romance spans 6,000 years; they appear as though they’re on their first awkward date.) The script occasionally delves into intriguing themes concerning the bonds between superheroes, mythology, and religion, but consistently abandons these concepts for repetitive action sequences involving dull monsters. It is challenging to conceive of a more tedious film about immortal alien robots striving to prevent universal destruction than this one.

35. The Incredible Hulk

The movie feels so disjointed, awkward, and unattractive, it’s as if Marvel was completely taken aback when Iron Man took off and they hastily produced this. Casting Tim Roth as the world’s supreme soldier (who transforms into a large bony monster resembling feces) is a decision Loki never made, even for his worst crimes. (For more details, see here.)

34. Thor: The Dark World

Almost having Patty Jenkins’ Thor, we ended up with a film that felt quite dreary. Instead of an exhilarating adventure, it turned into a tedious pursuit of a mystical object, with one of the least engaging villains in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. On a positive note, if this movie hadn’t underperformed as severely, Marvel might not have been open to experimenting as boldly as they did with Thor: Ragnarok (read more here).

33. The Marvels

This Marvel movie isn’t the most dismal – it surpasses three other films on the list – yet it’s arguably the most disorganized and intense. Three captivating Marvel characters (Brie Larson’s Captain Marvel, Iman Vellani’s Ms. Marvel, and Teyonah Parris’ Monica Rambeau) are haphazardly united to prevent a Kree warlord from causing havoc for reasons that remain unclear. Despite the actors delivering strong performances, the plot, though concise, is chaotic and filled with peculiar decisions that seem illogical.

32. Captain America: Brave New World

Incorrect setting, appropriate hero: This phrase aptly applies to several underwhelming Marvel films (including “The Marvels”) and is particularly true of “Captain America: New World Order,” which finally grants Anthony Mackie’s charming Sam Wilson a solo film, but then pairs him with a dull villain and a narrative littered with unnecessary references to “The Incredible Hulk” (leaving us all on the edge of our seats about Betty Ross’ fate?).

31. Doctor Strange

In a nutshell, the visually stunning aspects of “Doctor Strange” are commendable, but it fails to shake off the sensation that it’s just an upgraded version of “Iron Man 2,” with a dash of magic. The film earns a thumbs-up for its clever ending involving Dormammu, but the wacky cape worn by Strange receives a thumbs-down. You can read more about it [here](link to the source).

The movie “Doctor Strange” is visually impressive, but it still feels like a modified version of “Iron Man 2 with magic.” The ending with Dormammu is clever, but the cape worn by Strange could use some improvement. Read more about it [here](link to the source).

30. Iron Man 2

Surprisingly good, yet far from exceptional. Sam Rockwell’s dancing skillfully masks many flaws, but not all. By trimming 15 minutes of the setup in Avengers, it could potentially be something quite impressive. (Read more here.)

Quite improved compared to your memory, yet still leaves room for improvement. Sam Rockwell’s dancing skillfully conceals many imperfections, but not all. Eliminating 15 minutes of the setup in Avengers might result in something truly remarkable. (Read more here.)

29. Ant-Man

The film Ant-Man isn’t terrible, but it feels like a smaller-scale version of what could have been the Edgar Wright movie we were expecting. Despite this, Michael Peña’s character Luis stands out as one of the best non-superpowered characters in the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. (For more details, read here.)

Here’s another option:

Ant-Man is alright, but it leaves you feeling like you’re watching a scaled-down version of what could have been an Edgar Wright blockbuster. However, Michael Peña’s character Luis shines as one of the most memorable non-superpowered characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. (More details can be found here.)

And a third option:

Ant-Man is decent enough, but it falls short of what we might have gotten if Edgar Wright had directed it. Still, Michael Peña’s character Luis stands out as one of the most compelling non-superpowered characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. (Further information can be found here.)

28. Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania

Stepping into the shoes of a mere Ant-Man against Kang the Conqueror, as even the intimidating Jonathan Majors puts it, I’m clearly out of my depth. This David versus Goliath scenario mirrors the film itself quite aptly: The quaint, low-stakes universe of the Ant-Man series with its charming humor and relatable characters seems almost trivial next to the grandiose multiversal saga unfolding in Marvel Phase 5.

On the big screen, it’s a Marvel adventure that gets the job done. However, as an extension of the Ant-Man storyline, it leaves a bit to be desired, especially for those expecting more of Michael Peña’s delightful character, Luis, since he is noticeably absent from this installment.

27. Ant-Man and the Wasp

The movie “Ant-Man and the Wasp” shines brightest when it emphasizes its simplicity, as Paul Rudd cracks jokes with his fellow actors, Michael Peña delivers heartfelt monologues, and a tender, family-focused story unfolds about a fractured family striving to heal and reunite. (Read more .)

26. Captain Marvel

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Brie Larson’s portrayal of Carol Danvers could be the most potent hero, yet her movie seemed to fall short emotionally. Despite this, it remains engaging due to two standout performances: Ben Mendelsohn as the cunning Skrull Talos and Samuel L. Jackson (and impressive de-aging effects) as the youthful Nick Fury. (Continue reading .)

Brie Larson’s character, Carol Danvers, may be the strongest hero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but her movie missed a bit of emotional depth. However, it remains captivating thanks to two exceptional actors: Ben Mendelsohn as the clever Skrull Talos and Samuel L. Jackson (and remarkable de-aging visuals) portraying the young Nick Fury. (Read more .)

25. Black Widow

2021 saw Scarlett Johansson’s long-awaited solo outing from the Avengers, but instead of taking center stage, she primarily served as a straight character to the humorously eccentric Russian superhero crew, including David Harbour’s self-absorbed Red Guardian and Florence Pugh’s captivating Yelena. Consequently, Black Widow might not have been the fitting farewell the character deserved. Nevertheless, it remains a well-crafted Marvel production, boasting some thrilling action scenes, and an intriguing villain in the shape of Taskmaster, who has the ability to copy the combat moves of any adversary he encounters.

24. Thor: Love and Thunder

Experiencing Taika Waititi’s second Thor movie, “Thor: Love and Thunder,” seems somewhat like observing a magician performing the same trick twice in rapid succession. The first time was mind-blowing. The second time is still captivating, but it lacks the initial surprise factor. Christian Bale delivers a chilling performance as Gorr the God-Butcher, yet his intense and highly emotional villain doesn’t quite harmonize with Chris Hemsworth’s Thor and his constant joking. Essentially, “Thor: Love and Thunder” retains all the components of Waititi’s “Thor: Ragnarok,” but they don’t blend as effortlessly this time around.

23. Deadpool & Wolverine

In this film, the camaraderie between Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman is exactly what you’d expect – it’s fantastic, even surprising at times. The plot, however, pushes the limits of how much background information a movie can have without becoming confusing. (It seems like each character has their own share of tragic pasts, which could be too much for one film!) If you manage not to think about anything happening on screen for even a moment, you’ll likely have an enjoyable experience. The duo effectively portrays Deadpool and Wolverine reluctantly teaming up to save the Fox X-Men universe. You might find yourself wishing that the writers (including Reynolds) had delivered a slightly more coherent storyline instead.

22. Captain America: The Winter Soldier

A revised take on the film “Iron Man 2“: Less enjoyable than you might recall, but still worth a watch. The promotion emphasized the conspiracy thriller aspect too strongly, yet Anthony Mackie’s Falcon significantly strengthens the series, and Chris Evans maintains his reliable portrayal of Captain America. However, it remains frustrating that Nick Fury, the world’s most accomplished spy, was oblivious to the fact that nearly everyone in SHIELD except him and his two associates were corrupt. Really, Nick? Wake up! (For further reading, click here.)

21. Avengers: Infinity War

This film certainly boasts an impressive scale and a climactic ending that’s worth remembering, but it leaves you feeling like something crucial is lacking. If you’re primarily seeking high-octane action with some witty quips, then this might just be what you’re after. However, if you appreciate the characters, their interactions, and the quieter scenes amidst the battles, then this movie may not fully satisfy your expectations. (For a more detailed review, click here.)

20. Iron Man 3

The film was quite enjoyable, yet its quality was slightly diminished by the extensive Marvel Cinematic Universe context. The movie’s plot culminates in Tony Stark deciding to leave his Iron Man life behind and ride off into the sunset. However, this was followed by an additional five films. Although Guy Pearce’s character, Killian, fell short of expectations, Robert Downey Jr.’s exchanges with a clever child were top-notch. (You can read more about it [here].)

19. Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings

Initially, let me clarify: The climactic scene featuring dragons and monsters amidst a thick gray fog is visually displeasing due to poor CGI. However, prior to this point, Shang-Chi could be Marvel’s finest action movie, boasting numerous intense and complex fight sequences. (The one on the San Francisco bus is particularly enjoyable.) Simu Liu headlines an emotionally resonant Marvel ensemble, with Tony Leung and Michelle Yeoh delivering nuanced supporting performances, while Ben Kingsley and Awkwafina provide consistent comic relief. (Kingsley as Trevor Slattery, the former Mandarin, may not have been a popular Marvel villain initially, but Marvel has cleverly transformed him into an endearing side character.).

18. Thor

An expansive tale, stretching across the universe, primarily unfolding in … the tiniest town of New Mexico? The film Thor, despite its flaws, stands out as the first Marvel movie where exceptional acting and captivating performances managed to surpass structural and script problems, a trait that later became synonymous with Marvel productions. (Continue reading here.)

17. Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

In the task of directing “Wakanda Forever”, Ryan Coogler encountered an extraordinarily tough predicament. Not only was he required to create a sequel worthy of the original “Black Panther”, but he had to accomplish this feat without Chadwick Boseman, our charming lead actor, who tragically passed away during the summer of 2020, just as filming was set to commence. The movie truly shines when it incorporates Coogler and the cast’s profound grief over Boseman into the narrative of Wakanda grappling with the loss of its monarch. Regrettably, the remainder of the film is somewhat disorganized; a conglomeration of intriguing concepts, an abundance of characters, and a villain, King Namor, whose motivations are somewhat unclear.

16. Captain America: Civil War

As I reflect on this movie, it barely withstands a moment’s examination, with the entire plot seemingly engineered to culminate in the epic showdown between Tony Stark and Steve Rogers at the airport. Yet, let me tell you, that battle was absolutely thrilling! (You can read more about it here.)

15. Spider-Man: No Way Home

In Jon Watts’ third Spider-Man movie, its quality is similar to Sam Raimi’s third Spider-Man film. Both share a common issue of having too many villains. On the bright side, this film effectively portrays Peter Parker as a character who consistently strives despite frequent failures and attempts to rectify his mistakes. Moreover, it significantly introduces the concept of the multiverse into MCU films, thereby setting an important precedent in the storyline’s development.

Jon Watts’ third Spider-Man film is comparable in quality to Sam Raimi’s third Spider-Man movie, with both featuring a large number of villains. Nevertheless, it excels in its portrayal of Peter Parker as a character who persists despite his frequent shortcomings and seeks to improve each time. Additionally, the movie paves the way for the multiverse concept in MCU films, making a significant impact on the saga’s progression.

14. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness

Following a 15-year absence, film director Sam Raimi re-entered the Marvel universe with an exhilaratingly chaotic tale centered on a struggle for the survival of the multiverse. Similar to his previous Spider-Man films, Raimi cleverly incorporated his unique elements – whimsical humor, maniacal zombies, and sudden jumps – into the conventional Marvel storyline. (For further details, see here.)

13. Thunderbolts (2025)

As a fan of Marvel’s cinematic universe, I must admit that some of their post-“Endgame” projects seem like pieced-together content from various comics, films, and lore. However, “Thunderbolts*” feels distinctly different – it’s more like a standalone movie with a captivating narrative and intriguing characters, particularly Florence Pugh as the new Black Widow. Her character, much like many of us, finds herself trapped in a life she despises and a job that offers no fulfillment.

However, things change when she’s thrown into a group of similarly disgruntled mercenaries, including Wyatt Russell’s cocky U.S. Agent and Hannah John-Kamen’s enigmatic Ghost. The action is fun, the plot effective, and the allegory about overcoming despair and apathy through action and camaraderie is particularly poignant.

In essence, “Thunderbolts*” serves as a timely reminder of Marvel Studio’s potential when they’re operating at their peak.

12. Avengers: Age of Ultron

Despite some criticisms about its decline from the initial Avengers film and issues with Wanda and Pietro’s storyline, I remain baffled by the widespread dislike for this movie. Its climactic scene, where the Avengers band together to rescue every remaining soul in Sokovia, epitomizes the essence of Marvel at its finest. (Continue reading .)

11. Guardians of the Galaxy, Vol. 2

The film is excessively lengthy, featuring no less than four post-credit scenes. Yet, its audacity in transforming Marvel’s most lighthearted series into a sequel with such a somber ending is noteworthy. This movie is the sole Marvel production that manages to bring tears to my eyes and still includes jokes about cosmic deity phallic symbols. In my opinion, this unique blend of emotions makes it an outstanding piece. (Read more here.)

10. Thor: Ragnarok

I just really like when Jeff Goldblum plays a space god who DJs his own parties. (Read more here.)

9. Spider-Man: Far From Home

In the second Spidey movie by Marvel, starring Tom Holland as the captivating Spider-Man, the film slightly falls short of its predecessor yet remains engaging with ample doses of romance, action, humor, and emotion. Although the phrase “with great power comes great responsibility” isn’t explicitly used, the film “Far From Home” carries this theme as strongly as any other Spider-Man production. Peter Parker, portrayed by Holland, finds himself torn between his affection for MJ, played by the witty Zendaya, and his duty to thwart a group of elemental villains ordered by Nick Fury, portrayed by a frustrated Samuel L. Jackson.

8. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3

James Gunn delivers a spectacular finale to his Guardians trilogy, blending the perfect Marvel cocktail: Thrilling action sequences, quirky science fiction visuals, and characters who we deeply care about. By the end of Volume 3, Rocket Raccoon has evolved from a B-list Marvel character to one of the company’s most intriguing and heartbreaking heroes. After a series of less impressive films, Gunn makes it seem effortless. It’s unfortunate that he is moving on to work with DC instead.

7. Avengers: Endgame

A significant leap forward from “Infinity War” and arguably one of the finest Avengers films yet, featuring grand scale action sequences, numerous humorous moments, and potentially more Easter eggs than any film in the annals of any cinematic universe. (For further details, click here.)

6. Spider-Man: Homecoming

Among the most enjoyable Marvel Cinematic Universe films, this one boasts engaging characters, thrilling web-slinging scenes, and an unexpected street vendor requesting Spider-Man to perform a flip (which he does). Aren’t you captivated? (For further details, check out the article here.)

5. Guardians of the Galaxy

In the middle of Marvel Cinematic Universe’s timeline so far, the initial Guardians film played a crucial role in showcasing Marvel’s ability to entertain audiences with lesser-known properties. Before James Gunn took over, the Guardians were almost an afterthought, but he transformed them into a massive hit. It’s also indisputable that Rocket is the best of the Guardians – this is not up for debate, so just acknowledge it as true. (You can read more about it [here].)

4. Captain America: The First Avenger

Despite some structural issues, such as condensing an entire war into a montage, Chris Evans’ portrayal of Captain America stands out as a remarkable adaptation in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. This film transformed a character often criticized for being too bland or outdated into a dynamic, appealing, multi-layered individual embodying fundamental human virtues. A must-watch when seeking inspiration. (Read more here.)

3. Black Panther

In contrast to many Marvel films that strive for extensive cosmic links, “Black Panther” demonstrates the merit of a more secluded narrative style. Towards the end of the movie, when Black Panther decides to reveal Wakanda to the outside world (and the characters become available for future appearances), it’s intended as a joyful resolution. However, if this decision leads to a sequel that is less focused and includes numerous guest appearances, it might not be so delightful after all. (Read more here.)

2. The Avengers

Despite the events in “Infinity War”, the original “Avengers” movie remains an unbelievable masterpiece. Each character is skillfully balanced, the script is concise, and the climactic Battle of New York stands as one of the exceptional action sequences from this century. (Read more here.)

1. Iron Man

Looking back, I firmly believe that no film has surpassed the original one I’m talking about. The unique aspect of this movie, not being bound to a broader universe, allowed it to excel as a film. The scenes where Robert Downey Jr.’s character, Tony Stark, tests his armor and then takes flight for the first time, perfectly encapsulate the exhilaration of superpowers better than any movie ever made by Marvel or anyone else in history.

Read More

2025-05-05 16:28